The peace accord in Northern Ireland, settled between Catholics and Protestants on Good Friday 1998, continues to be cited as an American diplomatic success. But it is showing signs of coming unstuck again, a development exacerbated by Brexit machinations in the United Kingdom.
The coalition government in Belfast, called the Stormont government after the parliament building in which it meets, collapsed last January. That government joins Catholic nationalists with Protestant unionists, who favor continued union with the United Kingdom. The nationalists favor reunification with the Catholic south of the island, although there are gradations of positions on both sides. The Good Friday agreement was preceded by decades of deplorable violence between the two sides with the British seeking to keep order.
Rivalries within the Northern Irish political scene are based both on position and personal history, making their resolution even more difficult. Sinn Fein, the major nationalist party, had demanded the resignation of Arlene Foster, the head of the principal Protestant party, the Democratic Unionist Party, for corruption. Gerry Adams, the head of Sinn Fein, has announced his retirement at the end of the year. In the meantime, London, in the form of the British Parliament, in the absence of the Stormont government, has moved back toward “direct rule” by the United Kingdom in Northern Ireland.
London, of course, is preoccupied with implementing last year’s referendum vote to leave the European Union. Brexit has direct impact on both Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic. The border between the two is completely open with both as members of the EU. It will become an international border between them if and when the United Kingdom leaves the EU, confounding trade as well as traffic between them, important to both.
The London government, led by Prime Minister Theresa May, is weak. The Dublin government is threatened by the possibility of imminent snap elections, undesired by most Irish voters and brought about, if they occur, by basically inconsequential wrangling within the Irish government.
As for repairing the Stormont Good Friday agreement, it will not be easy given the state of internal Northern Irish politics, the weakness of the governments in Dublin and London, looming Brexit and lingering Protestant-Catholic hatred. As for American help in resolving the problem, there is no chance of that at this time. Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, and now President Donald Trump, have showed no interest in involving themselves in intra-Irish pushing and pulling, preferring to see the Good Friday agreement as a success to cite, but not America’s problem.
Nor is it. If the Irish can’t work it out, particularly given the formula for cooperation they arrived at with help 19 years ago, what is there for the rest of us to do? At the same time, given the fondness of Americans for the Irish in general, it is hard to watch with indifference.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.