Parties to the Syrian war — so far appropriately excluding the United States — are beginning the process of determining what the country becomes. The murderous, destructive war is coming to an end after years of conflict.
It has been a hybrid war — in part a civil war among Syrians, but also with substantial involvement in it by external parties. In addition, reconstruction, wrapping up the war and preserving a sustainable peace will require assistance from the external parties involved. All this means that other countries are going to have to be involved in crafting a postwar Syria.
The big players are already being led by President Vladimir Putin’s Russia. Visitors to Moscow on the subject have included Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Iranian President Hassan Rouhani and leaders from Saudi Arabia. The fragmented so-called Syrian opposition has reportedly boiled itself down to a 50-person delegation to be represented at eventual talks. Smaller, questionable interested parties include the Kurds, whose U.S.-backed troops still occupy parts of northeast Syria, and Lebanon-based Hezbollah, currently pulling out of Syria but still interested. Israel, which has operated pretty much behind the scenes in the Syrian war, will play a role. Israel had a dog in the fight in both the Iraq and Syria wars, which more or less neutralized both countries and their armed forces as threats to Israel.
The United States played a relatively limited role in the Syrian affair. President Barack Obama started out, in harmony with the Middle East’s Arab Spring, declaring that Syrian President Bashar Assad had to go. That turned out to be wrong, based on misanalysis of Russia’s stake in the Assads, dating from the Cold War, and Russia’s continued interest in a naval base on the Mediterranean, in Syria. To the degree that the Syrian war became a proxy war between the United States and Russia, the U.S. came up short. Or it could be that Mr. Obama estimated, probably correctly, that Americans did not have a stomach for yet another larger war in the region, adding to those in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Somalia and Yemen.
The U.S. is thus left with its inconclusive support of some anti-Assad Syrian elements and its larger backing of the Kurdish forces that took the Islamic State’s capital, Raqqa, in Syria’s northeast. It would be seriously unwise for the U.S. to seek to sustain the Kurdish forces in Syria, particularly given U.S. NATO ally Turkey’s profound opposition to such action and the general problem that Kurdish irredentism poses in the region, including in Iraq, where the U.S. is seeking to strengthen the government in Baghdad.
Russia and the other parties may seek at some point to involve the United States in the Syria postwar discussions. There is no need for the U.S. to seek an invitation to participate in that affair, no more than there was to have deepened U.S. involvement in the war in its hotter stage. U.S. policy backed the Kurds in taking Raqqa in order to weaken the Islamic State. That made sense. Involving ourselves in sorting out and putting back together postwar Syria does not. Its ethnic and religious composition with a majority being Sunni Muslims, ruled by religiously idiosyncratic minority Alawites led by the Assad family, is still a mess, after a bloody war that has trashed a good part of the country. Syria now is not our problem.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.