A 500-year-old painting of Christ called “Salvator Mundi,” purportedly painted by Leonardo da Vinci, fetched a record $400 million at auction Nov. 15. Despite what many art experts consider a questionable provenance, damage to the painting’s surface by aggressive cleaning and its dubious quality — a New York Times art critic said it was “no Mona Lisa” — Christie’s New York mounted a superb pre-auction sales campaign to unload it for nearly a half-billion dollars (the auctioneer’s fees tacked on $50 million to the price).
No single painting or work of art has ever sold for as much or come close. Even the art market, which perversely ignores the way supply and demand work much of the time, responded to the lead-up to the bidding and its aftermath with justifiable astonishment. Almost a half-billion bucks for a Leonardo painting that qualifies as one of his minor works?
Let’s face it: The painting of Christ, his right hand with its index and middle fingers extended in anticipation of bestowing a blessing and balanced by a mysterious, transparent orb in his left hand, is more curious than inspirational. What is the orb supposed to symbolize in the context of this particular painting? The vaguely occultish-looking Christ of “Salvator Mundi” looks more like a Florentine dilettante of the high Renaissance than a suffering savior. Though superficially attractive, it is at best a minor work. But that’s no knock on Leonardo: An artist whose overall output of civilization-defining work has latitude to dash off a clunker or two.
The fact that there is a debate about whether the composition of the painting is consistent with Leonardo da Vinci’s approach to painting should have given the bidders reason to pause, but it didn’t.
Many experts believe it may have been painted by one of Leonardo’s acolytes, a contemporary imitator of the artist or even a clever forger. That’s why the inability to nail down a definitive chain of possession through the centuries has raised eyebrows and caused murmurs of disbelief about its authenticity. How could anyone, including billionaires with millions to burn, risk perpetuating a hoax just to have bragging rights as the owner of a Leonardo da Vinci painting?
But there are plenty of people who consider the painting genuine regardless of its ultimate origin. These are people who consider the market itself the final arbiter of whether a painting is real or not and worth whatever value is imputed to it. “Salvator Mundi” entered the modern-day market in 2005 for $10,000. After extensive restoration, it changed hands several times, most recently fetching $127 million from a Russian oligarch. In recent years as the market for old masters has become even more volatile and competitive, there’s an added incentive on the part of those doing the bidding to believe auction house assurances that what’s on sale has been rigorously authenticated.
Even if “Salvator Mundi” is a Leonardo masterwork, there’s still the question of whether any painting is worth nearly a half-billion dollars. The pre-auction hype clearly distorted the art market and introduced a new threshold that the auction of another masterpiece someday will shatter on the way to the first billion-dollar work of art. Reasonable restraints appear to have fallen by the wayside.
Perhaps billion-dollar paintings are inevitable, given the whims of capitalism and the marketplace. But those who continue to nurse skepticism about whether it makes any sense shouldn’t be considered philistines.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.