President Donald Trump’s decision to keep in place the ban on the import into the United States of pieces of African animals was correct. It still isn’t entirely clear why he took that position, reversing a decision put forward by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, overseen by the Department of Interior. Most observers put it down to intervention by conservative conservationist donors, but it showed sound judgment on his part.
There are some questions where Americans and others should think of themselves as citizens and custodians of the world we live in. Not letting some of our world’s citizens eliminate from this earth animals like elephants, rhinos, lions and other species that are clearly under threat of that fate, based on their dropping numbers, is one of those issues. Bees are another.
One might imagine that even National Rifle Association members would have sense enough to stay away from the African animal parts issue. It appears, however, that the NRA took the position of favoring the continued import of trophy kills and pieces of animals slaughtered.
One argument that is sometimes made is that if the killing of animals in Africa is permitted, with appropriate license fees, the revenue can be used to finance the employment of game guards to protect the elephants, rhinos and others. Experience of that practice calls into serious question its efficacy. Corrupt officials in poor countries are often inclined to simply pocket the fees, rather than using them as professed.
A much more valid argument is that the Africans should see the profits of foreign tourism to visit and see the animals, thus providing them with a serious financial incentive to preserve them. This works in practice, with men and women employed as game guides, drivers and workers in tourist facilities in many capacities at reasonable wages.
It is beyond dispute that there may be nothing in anyone’s life experience more moving than seeing a lion at dawn walking back from his nightly hunting trip, or a family of elephants — they live in families, by the way, eating, birthing and mourning — drinking and stirring around at dusk.
What that means is that Americans should disregard their normal but pretty much unfounded fears of the hazards of travel in countries where these animals are found and go see them, if they have the ability to travel the distance. It also means that Americans should support fully all barriers to trade in trophies and parts of these animals taken in hunting. Mr. Trump has that issue right. Traffic in elephant tusks or powder from rhino horns is wrong, as well as disgusting.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.