When 62-year-old Ross Frye hanged himself Sept. 19 in the Allegheny County Jail, he became the fifth inmate to commit suicide there in the past 18 months. After a death, the jail typically re-evaluates its policies. Often, as in Mr. Frye’s case, it also disciplines staff.
But the spate of deaths requires something more — a better understanding of the epidemic of jail suicides nationwide. Jails across the nation should take stock of what has occurred just in the past week.
Last Monday, the Daily Commercial reported the suicide of 23-year-old Tyler R. Mraz in the Lake County Jail in Florida. Also last Monday, relatives filed a federal lawsuit against Washington County officials for failing to take action to prevent the 2015 suicide of 38-year-old Gregory Michaux Jr., who hanged himself with a bed sheet in the county jail.
The lawsuit says Mr. Michaux, locked up for about six months, made 104 pages of what he called “death notes” tragically documenting his suicidal thoughts and behavior. “Goodbye cruel world,” he said at one point. Another entry said, “Why do I keep failing at this? It can’t be that hard to die!” A third said, “Please God forgive my cowardness and let me enter ...” The suit says he was the third inmate to take his life there in eight months.
On Tuesday, The Roanoke Times reported that five inmates at the Virginia city’s jail have committed suicide since 2013, all by hanging. Also Wednesday, the Kansas City Star reported that 53-year-old Michael McNurlin committed suicide in the Jackson County Jail just four days after being sentenced to 80 years imprisonment for child sexual abuse.
Like the Allegheny County Jail, institutions in other places generally revisit policies and scrutinize staff after a suicide occurs. It isn’t enough.
This troubling trend has a long arc. Suicide has been the top cause of death in “local jails” from at least 2000 through 2013, according to a report two years ago by the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics.
The suicide rate at jails jumped 9 percent between 2012 and 2013 alone. Those dying by their own hands were overwhelmingly young (25 to 44 years old), male and burdened by drug and alcohol addiction. In comparison, most deaths at state prisons involve illnesses.
The reasons jail inmates are vulnerable to suicide are varied. For some, it may be what is called the “shock of confinement.” If incarceration is a new experience, they may see their world falling apart and panic, especially if their thinking is muddled by drug or alcohol use or mental illness. For recently sentenced inmates — perhaps McNurlin fell into this category — the prospect of lengthy prison time may be too much to bear.
Experts have documented many other warning signs over the years — such as the tendency for suicides to occur between 3 and 9 p.m., in proximity to telephone calls or visits from relatives and more often than not among inmates who aren’t on suicide watch.
It may be difficult to summon sympathy for inmates, but many of those in jails have been charged with crimes and are awaiting adjudication of their cases. Mr. Michaux was one of these so-called pretrial detainees. For inmates like him, a jail cell should be a weigh station, not a final destination.
It’s time corrections officials gathered all they know about jail suicides and put together a comprehensive strategy for addressing a far-reaching problem. After Mr. Frye’s death, the Allegheny County Jail ordered its officers to start carrying tools for cutting down inmates who attempt to hang themselves. While that may save a life here or there, a better prevention strategy is the wiser, more humane course.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.