Lt. Gov. Mike Stack has embarrassed his office and been of little help to his ostensible partner, Gov. Tom Wolf. But a state senator’s proposal to let gubernatorial nominees pick their running mates, rather than continuing to let the voters pick them, is an overreaction. It would be wrong to give voters less say in who governs them.
Pennsylvania is one of a handful of states in which voters separately elect nominees for the state’s top two executive-branch jobs. Candidates run for lieutenant governor just as they do for governor. In the 2014 primary, Democratic voters nominated Mr. Stack, who was a state senator from Philadelphia, for lieutenant governor and Mr. Wolf, a York County businessman, for governor. They ran as a ticket in the fall and defeated their Republican opponents in the general election.
Instead of helping Mr. Wolf run the state, however, Mr. Stack has been a drag. Last summer, when Mr. Stack wanted language in a bill that would have allowed his security detail to use flashing lights and sirens for reasons of convenience, Mr. Wolf’s office had to step in to thwart the foolhardy proposal. In April, Mr. Wolf asked the state inspector general to investigate reports that Mr. Stack and his wife, Tonya, had verbally abused state employees and that the lieutenant governor had encouraged his driver to ignore the speed limit. Two weeks later, without waiting for the IG’s report, Mr. Wolf took the unprecedented step of yanking Mr. Stack’s security detail and scaling back the staffing at the Stacks’ taxpayer-funded residence at Fort Indiantown Gap.
Mr. Wolf and Mr. Stack have a frosty relationship that only makes the job of running the state more difficult. Now, Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill, has proposed legislation that would allow gubernatorial nominees to select their running mates, much the way presidential candidates select theirs. Each political party would have to sign off on its lieutenant governor candidate. But voters would have no say until the general election, when they would choose a team from one party or another. The change would require a constitutional amendment — a time-consuming process that couldn’t be accomplished until after next year’s race for governor and lieutenant governor.
Mr. Argall said he wants to avoid another “forced political marriage” that disrupts state government. However, there’s no reason to suggest that gubernatorial candidates would choose better running mates than voters do, and one lieutenant governor’s dismal performance is no reason to change the way the office is filled. Mr. Stack’s example does raise the profile of next year’s race for lieutenant governor and underscores the importance of having a capable person in the position. Perhaps if more attention had been paid to the lieutenant governor’s race in 2014, the office would be in better hands today.
The voters have put good people in the position before. When Republican Gov. Tom Ridge resigned after 9/11 to become the nation’s first secretary of homeland security, Lt. Gov. Mark Schweiker took over the top spot. His handling of the 2002 Quecreek mine accident in Somerset County was especially good.
If a gubernatorial candidate wants to have some say about a running mate, he or she should line up behind a candidate for lieutenant governor in the primary, giving voters an early look at the chemistry between them. Diminishing the voters’ voice in the electoral process is a misguided idea that would add insult to the injury Mr. Stack has inflicted on the people of Pennsylvania. Mr. Stack’s resignation would be the best way out of a bad situation.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.