One would think Robert Mellow, the former state senator from Lackawanna County, might have disappeared into the woodwork for good following his 2012 guilty plea to a federal corruption charge. But no, he’s back, in a particularly galling way.
Mellow, 74, stripped of his $20,509-a-month pension following his plea, is trying to get the benefit restored. He and his attorneys have filed a petition to do so with the State Employees’ Retirement System, arguing he deserves the money because the federal conspiracy charge he pleaded guilty to isn’t comparable to any of the state crimes that can cost Pennsylvania officials their pensions. “The Pension Forfeiture Act ... cannot in any way be read to apply to conspiracy offenses,” they wrote.
How clever. Little wonder Mellow survived 40 years in Harrisburg’s rough-and-tumble political world, rising to Democratic leader and Senate president pro tem.
His story is a testament to the state’s fetid political culture and a reminder of the Legislature’s need to update the Pension Forfeiture Act to include offenses such as Mellow’s. Mellow belongs in the company of the long list of colleagues — including former Reps. Bill DeWeese and John Perzel and former Sen. Jane Orie — who lost their pensions because of various state crimes.
On one hand, it’s difficult to fault Mellow for coveting that whopping pension, a sum reflecting his longevity in office (term limits, anyone?), his leadership status and the generous multiplier in place for legislators of his generation. It’s the kind of pension that average Pennsylvanians can only help pay for, never hope to enjoy themselves.
On the other hand, one might think Mellow, charged with using state employees to do political work, would be sufficiently chastened by his crime and 16-month prison sentence to swear off the public trough for the rest of his life. “I’m embarrassed and I’m ashamed. ... I’m very, very sorry,” he said at his sentencing.
But the remorse didn’t last long. He wrote a book about his career and told the Times Leader of Wilkes-Barre last year that federal authorities forced his plea by wearing him down. “I had to get it over with. ... I don’t believe I did a thing wrong,” he said. “You can’t separate politics from government when you’re an elected person. They’re one and the same.” (The self-published book has a catchy title: “Used, Abused & Forgotten — Bob Mellow: A Targeted Senator.”)
If the pension is restored, Mellow would split it with his ex-wife. The retirement system board has no timetable for voting on Mellow’s request. While there is at least some precedent for what he is seeking — a corrections officer once used a similar argument to win back his pension — the retirement board should vote no and send the signal that public corruption will not be tolerated.
Mellow would have the right to appeal an unfavorable decision, all the way to the state Supreme Court if he chose. Let him do so. Let him spend more money and time on his unrighteous quest. The taxpayers of Pennsylvania have given him more than enough already.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.