It’s no exaggeration to say that the free speech movement at American universities began at the University of California Berkeley 50 years ago. Student rights activists who demonstrated for the cause received nightly news attention in California and beyond.

In those days, students at UC Berkeley fought for academic freedom and the right to protest on behalf of civil rights for African-Americans and against America’s deepening involvement in Vietnam. The university brass and the state’s political elite, however, insisted that students buckle down, study hard, cut their hair and shut up.

They didn’t. Free-speech protests at Berkeley were one of the accelerants of social change in America. Yet the students who fought for a vibrant environment for free speech and debate in the 1960s would be appalled by the actions today of other students at their alma mater.

Some students opposed to the university’s selection of controversial comedian and pundit Bill Maher to give the keynote graduation speech in December circulated petitions against the invitation. The students object to Mr. Maher’s criticism of Islam as the most violent and intolerant of the major religions.

Advertise with us

Mr. Maher, a prominent atheist, isn’t a fan of any faith, but he appears to have an antipathy for Islam that is uniquely obnoxious. Still, he has a right to his opinion — ill-informed or otherwise. Instead of trying to get Mr. Maher banned from campus, Berkeley students should ask to meet with him in a forum so they can express their dissent and listen to his defense.

On Wednesday university officials said that although the student committee in charge of speaker selection voted to rescind the invitation, the administration will not accept the panel’s decision and that the HBO host will speak.

No one ever said that free expression means having the right never to be offended. The students’ attempt to stifle Mr. Maher at the cradle of academic free speech sadly borders on satire.

Meet the Editorial Board