The 12th Congressional District winds its way across six counties — all of Beaver, southern Lawrence, northern Allegheny, northern Westmoreland, southern Cambria and northern Somerset. As diverse as its people and attitudes are, the choice for the voters turns on two simple perceptions: What sort of job is Congress doing and what part has their representative played in that?

Republican incumbent Keith Rothfus, a lawyer who lives in Sewickley, has spent his freshman term applying his conservative, Tea Party-style philosophy to the faithful service of his party. Some of this zeal is well-directed. Mr. Rothfus, 52, has stressed constituent service and has held more than 60 “coffees with Keith” that were open to the public.

On the flip side, he also voted with the Republicans in the House a year ago to shut down the government, which achieved nothing and cost the treasury billions, for which he blames Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid. He can’t even promise not to do it again in the future — he says it would depend on the circumstances. He has also voted multiple times to repeal the Affordable Care Act, the growing success of which he does not believe.

As it happens, the Democrat, Erin McClelland, 39, of Harrison brings a special expertise in health care to the race, an issue she is passionate about. Having obtained academic degrees in psychology, she started a nonprofit business specializing in addiction treatment. One of her pet causes is reducing medical errors. While she does not pretend that the Affordable Care Act is perfect, she would be a sincere and knowledgeable reformer of it.

Advertise with us

As for the government shutdown, Ms. McClelland calls it “appalling” and “unbelievably irresponsible” — and she is right. This issue among the many crystallizes the choice for us. If elected, she will be the only woman in the Pennsylvania congressional delegation.

All the constituent service in the world counts for nothing if you refuse to do the job the constituents elected you to do, and then blame someone else. The Post-Gazette endorses the high-energy Erin McClelland.

Meet the Editorial Board