Neighbors are calling it a comedy of errors, but there is nothing funny about the slow-motion reconstruction of a four-block section of Penn Avenue in Garfield.
It’s been more than a year since contractors started tearing up the major artery between Mathilda and Evaline streets, which meant no outbound traffic for months. Although two-way traffic is supposed to resume soon, all of the work won’t be completed until sometime next year, way behind schedule.
Cost overruns have plagued the project, too, with the price tag now at least $800,000 higher than the original $4.7 million estimate. Count among the troubles broken water lines, underground utilities that weren’t shown on maps, old streetcar tracks unearthed and contaminated soil that surrounded them. The snags were unfortunate, but they aren’t unusual obstacles when old infrastructure is being replaced; the city and its contractor should have been able to rebound more quickly from the setbacks.
People who live and work near the site assign more blame to what they say were long periods of inactivity and slow responses to emergencies. For instance, Rick Swartz, executive director of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp., said a water leak was not repaired for more than two months.
The project took a decade to plan, yet right from the start residents and business owners weren’t happy. Mr. Swartz said they’d been told that work would happen two blocks at a time, but on day one, restrictions went into effect on all four blocks and, shortly after that, a fifth block was fenced in for use as a storage site for construction materials.
The timing couldn’t have been worse. Long dormant, the neighborhood has been coming alive with an influx of new enterprises and restaurants. With a hole literally ripped in the middle of the community, though, businesses suffered from a drop in customers.
The experience is making neighbors apprehensive about the next phase of work, from Evaline to Aiken Avenue. The contractors and the city owe the community two things: prompt completion of the first phase and a more efficient performance in round two.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.