Voters in the 33rd House District have a tough choice on Nov. 4 — stick with a smart, senior lawmaker or take a chance on a bright, thoughtful newcomer. After 22 years in office, Rep. Frank Dermody’s clout in Harrisburg gives him the advantage in serving the Allegheny River Valley.

The district includes New Kensington, Arnold, Oakmont, Cheswick, East Deer, Frazer, Harmar, Indiana, Tarentum, Brackenridge, Springdale borough and township and part of Harrison.

Republican challenger Sean Watson, 34, of East Deer is a small-businessman who represents makers of sustainable building products to contractors. He said he’s running because he wants the responsibility of making the state better for his children and other Pennsylvanians.

Mr. Dermody, 63, is a Democrat from Oakmont who still enjoys the politics of the job, which he says enables him to help fix Pennsylvania’s problems. He believes the state will have a new governor in January, which would increase the legislator’s influence in the House even if the Republicans keep control.

Advertise with us

The candidates share views on some issues and differ on others. Mr. Dermody said he favored the funding proposals in last year’s transportation bill but voted against it because of changes it would have made to the prevailing wage law. Mr. Watson said he would have given the bill serious consideration. The challenger is intrigued by replacing school property taxes with higher sales and income taxes; the incumbent says that allowing for more flexibility on the mix of school taxes would be preferable.

Mr. Dermody favors a 5 percent extraction tax on gas drillers, wants to see Act 120 be given time to reduce the public pension burden, backs modernization instead of privatization of the liquor system and calls himself pro-choice on abortion. Mr. Watson is leery of a new drilling tax, favors a 401(k) savings plan for new public employees, wants to get the state out of the liquor business and says he is pro-life.

Voters will choose, of course, based on the issues that matter to them, and that’s what elections are all about. But it would be hard for a novice to top the ability of Frank Dermody to move a bill or get attention for the needs of the district.

Meet the Editorial Board

Correction, posted Oct. 16, 2014: In an earlier version of this editorial, Rep. Frank Dermody's position on the 2013 transportation bill was misstated.