Former Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin stands disgraced for crimes that basically boil down to ripping off Pennsylvania taxpayers by using state time and resources to do political campaign work. The problem is she refuses to be disgraced. While it is her right to keep up her appeals, the public has a right not to be sympathetic.
Irritation is the more appropriate emotion, because this is the case that won’t go away. Somewhere in Pennsylvania a poor defendant sits in a cell marveling at the fact that “do the crime, do the time” doesn’t seem to apply to those accused in the ranks of the high and mighty. It is now up to the state Supreme Court to show that justice can be done.
In sentencing her in May 2013, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Lester Nauhaus should have sent her to prison. But he tried to shame her by ordering that she be photographed in handcuffs, write notes of apology on the pictures and send them to every judge in Pennsylvania — this on top of being sentenced to three years’ house arrest, two years’ probation, community service and a $55,000 fine.
It was a ridiculous sentence, inviting appeals that have set the scene for the latest stage of absurdity. A recent decision by Superior Court should have been the last word. While upholding the six charges, the court said she didn’t have to send apologies written on photos of herself in handcuffs to members of the judiciary, although she did have to write letters of apology in the interest of rehabilitation.
But the former justice appealed to the Supreme Court, putting her former colleagues in an embarrassing position. On Tuesday, they issued a stay of the sentence — for the third time in 18 months — while the court decides whether it will agree to hear her appeal.
They refused to set aside just the apology portion of the sentence. That is logical, but a small victory for logic is not yet a big victory for justice. The Supreme Court needs to confirm her disgrace — and sentence — soon.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.