It’s back. An idea that was kicked around Pittsburgh beginning at least 25 years ago has resurfaced. Public officials and the public need to tread carefully.
Mayor Bill Peduto says he and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald have asked the Sports & Exhibition Authority to study the feasibility of constructing a second hotel connected to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center.
Although calls two decades ago for a hotel proposed 1,000 rooms, the facility being envisioned now would have about 500, complementing the 616 rooms at the Westin hotel that is connected to the convention center by a sky bridge.
The reason always given — and which Mr. Peduto reiterates — for Pittsburgh to add significant hotel space next to the convention center is so it can attract the large conventions that continue to elude the city. How can Pittsburgh compete for events as large as the Democratic and Republican national conventions, major trade groups or other mega meetings when so much of its hotel space is scattered around Downtown, not to mention between Moon, McCandless and Monroeville?
The idea makes sense until the conversation turns to cost. No developer that has flirted with the idea in Pittsburgh has done so without proposing a major public subsidy as part of the financing. State Sen. Wayne Fontana, chairman of the SEA board, said the last round of proposals sought at least $50 million in public help. Any feasibility study by the SEA must look at the options for how to pay for a subsidy and no proposal should be taken seriously until the public’s ability to handle the cost is fleshed out.
Anyone who has been Downtown lately can see for themselves how the hotel business has taken off in recent years. New facilities are accommodating visitors not only in the Golden Triangle but also in the neighboring zones of the North Shore, Strip District, South Side and Uptown.
That should spell both encouragement and caution for the notion of a new, large hotel. This resurrected idea deserves more than attention; it deserves flinty-eyed scrutiny.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.