Eric H. Holder Jr., President Barack Obama’s able attorney general for more than five years, announced his resignation Thursday, which is likely to be followed by a partisan Senate battle over his replacement.

For any president the attorney general is the point person for the marching column, the lightning rod on top of the barn. In addition to the role Mr. Holder has played in carrying out the administration’s approach to law and justice since 2009, Mr. Holder was also the senior African-American man on the first African-American president’s team. He was respected by some and hated by others, but was always acknowledged to have the president’s ear and to reflect his domestic policies.

Mr. Holder led the way on a range of controversial issues, heartening civil rights advocates in particular. He sought to protect voters’ rights, seeing some states’ and courts’ positions as efforts to take America back to the 19th century. He tried to remove race as a factor in criminal justice through prison reforms for nonviolent drug offenders. In 2011 he announced that the Justice Department would no longer enforce the Defense of Marriage Act, opening the door for same-sex couples to wed.

Yet he offended liberals mightily by signing on to National Security Agency and other government spying on Americans. He riled conservatives with Fast and Furious, the Justice Department’s botched gun-trafficking operation. He did not respect the use of confidential sources by journalists to keep Americans informed about government. His department defended broad war-making powers for the president and accepted the president’s right to order the killing of Americans deemed by U.S. security agencies to be terrorists.

Advertise with us

For some Republicans there will be a period of unseemly rejoicing at Mr. Holder’s departure. At the same time, they must not be allowed to block the choice of an effective successor as America’s chief law enforcement officer. Every president needs an adroit attorney general, and America needs one to function as a fair society.

Meet the Editorial Board.