Given that nobody gets out of this life alive, it would be wise for every American to think about a plan for dying while still living. But because this is a subject few want to think about, the system for caring for dying Americans is itself chronically sick — costly and inefficient.
That is basically the conclusion of a timely and important report released last Wednesday by the Institute of Medicine, an independent, nonprofit organization that is the health arm of the National Academy of Sciences. The report — “Dying in America, Improving Quality and Honoring Individual Preferences Near the End of Life” — ought to be the starting point of a national conversation.
The key findings of the 21-member panel cover almost every aspect of health care for the dying. Concerning people’s preferences, the reports says that “more than a quarter of all adults, including those age 75 or older, have given little or no thought to their end-of-life wishes.”
The report wants people to be able to discuss with their doctors their preferences well before it is too late. For this to happen under Medicare, the main source of coverage for the elderly, Congress would have to act.
The report also stresses the benefits of palliative care with its focus on relief from pain and quality of life. “All people with advanced serious illness should have access to palliative care, or when appropriate, hospice care, in all settings where they receive care ...” Perversely, though, the system actually encourages “a reliance on acute care settings that are often costly and poorly suited to the needs, goals and preferences of patients and their families.”
But to suggest that there may be a more natural, dignified and less costly way of dying is to invoke the specter of “death panels.” As the very first words in the report recall, a bill to allow Medicare to pay for doctors to give counseling about living wills and end-of-life treatment was suggested as part of the Affordable Care Act, but was demagogued by pundits and politicians. A conversation to get past such folly is still one the nation is dying to have.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.