Talk about learning the wrong lesson. Like some other states that have reacted unwisely to school shootings, Pennsylvania lawmakers are considering a bill to allow teachers to carry firearms on school property. In other words, the suggested remedy for too many guns in America causing too much mayhem is more guns.

Senate Bill 1193 would not force teachers to be armed. It would permit school districts to let teachers carry guns at school if they have a concealed firearm license and maintain a certification in firearm use from an approved training program.

At a Senate Education Committee hearing Tuesday, Sen. Don White, R-Indiana, the prime sponsor of the bill, spoke of returning from the mass stabbings at Franklin Regional High School where police responded quickly and thinking what might have happened if the school had been in a rural area where assistance was 25 to 40 minutes away.

This theoretical scenario is certainly alarming and it might be comforting to think that a teacher with a gun could stop an armed intruder. But like all such scenarios, reality intrudes. Despite all the attention they get, mass shootings at schools are relatively rare events; rarer still do the police not arrive swiftly. Mr. White’s hypothetical describes a situation that has not been a big problem.

Advertise with us

If the police did arrive late to a rural school under attack, how are they to know who is the attacker and who is the armed teacher? Moreover, just because someone has a gun, a license and firearms training does not mean that he or she is capable of shooting someone, particularly in the heat of the moment. That is why military recruits and police candidates receive weeks of intense training. A gun fight is a job for a trained law enforcement officer.

Besides, where are armed teachers to stow their guns so that curious students don’t pick them up if they happen to leave the classroom? Arming teachers makes as much sense as arming ticket clerks at the cinema to protect the audience from shootings.

SB 1193 is a step away from civilized society and a step onto the set of “Gunsmoke.” At least in the Wild West they left Marshal Dillon to deal with the bad guys.

Meet the Editorial Board.