Americans can congratulate the people of the United Kingdom, and in particular, Scotland, on the outcome and process of the referendum on Scottish independence.
The results Thursday night were a clear 55 percent to 45 percent affirmation of the Scots’ desire to remain in the United Kingdom along with England, Northern Ireland and Wales. Turnout was a stunning 85 percent of the 4.3 million registered voters. Only four of Scotland’s 32 council areas voted Yes for independence.
The clarity of the voters’ decision and the positions taken by key leaders, including Prime Minister David Cameron, argue for no repeat of the referendum in the foreseeable future. As Mr. Cameron said, “no disputes, no reruns” and, as some Britons called it, no “never-end-ums,” which is fortunate for the country in planning its future.
There will be changes. London-based politicians campaigning for the No vote promised the Scots increased powers to the Scottish parliament, including taxation authority and more decision-making over tax receipts division. It is possible that the other three parts of the United Kingdom will benefit from further devolution of power from London.
Other secessionist elements were watching the Scottish referendum. One was the Catalans in Spain, who are hampered by the Spanish constitution’s requirement that the whole country vote on any secession move. Another was Quebec in Canada, although that movement is in effect out of business based on votes in 1980 and 1995. In Belgium, the Flemish-Walloon fissure has shown itself incapable of solution by any means.
Any parallel with the effort of American states to secede from the union in 1861, which was ended by the Civil War, doesn’t hold up since it wasn’t nationalism that prompted the Southern states’ effort to opt out, but the desire to preserve slavery.
The Scots and the British in general handled this process well. The United States would have found a truncated United Kingdom a more difficult ally to work with if the Scots had voted Yes.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.