The Peduto administration has arranged a marriage for the Strip District’s landmark produce terminal, one that it hopes will result in a long and happy life.

The Urban Redevelopment Authority, which owns the 1,533-foot-long warehouse, had three offers for repurposing the 88-year-old building — two that would have consisted mainly of housing and one that would have created a huge marketplace featuring small vendors and big, close-out retailers.

Instead of giving one developer exclusive development rights, the URA gave two of them — Chicago’s McCaffery Interests and a local group, Rubino Partners — three months to work together on a joint plan. There are a lot of questions about how this shotgun marriage can work, but Kevin Acklin, Mayor Bill Peduto’s chief of staff who also is chairman of the URA, said both firms have agreed to look into the possibility.

Even before last week’s decision, the mayor had done the right thing by preventing demolition of one-third of the terminal building. Earlier this year, he persuaded the Buncher Co., which previously held rights to develop the building, to give the city time to come up with other offers. It wasn’t cheap. Buncher was paid $640,000.

Advertise with us

But that deal gave rise to the latest idea for the joint venture.

Fourth Economy, the firm hired by the URA to analyze all three offers for the terminal project, favored McCaffery because of its financing plan and ability to generate future tax revenue. Mr. Acklin called it the “head” in this arrangement.

The Rubino plan is the “heart,” because it would have expanded on the Strip District’s history as an eclectic commercial corridor for fresh produce, local specialties and bargains.

If Mr. Acklin gets his preference, the URA or the city itself would retain ownership of the building, rent it to the dual developers for 99 years and collect taxes on it. That would keep the historic Pennsylvania Fruit Auction and Sales Building in public hands. This arranged marriage may be a way to keep an important heirloom in the family.

Meet the Editorial Board.