President Barack Obama Wednesday night addressed the American people’s most serious concern, their security, but set out changes in Middle East policy that, if carried out, will create more problems than they solve.

Americans are worried and angry about the new Islamic State, created by Sunni Islamist militants in Iraq and Syria. Mr. Obama has the Air Force already bombing the organization’s facilities and leaders in Iraq. In his talk he added the possibility of expanding the campaign to include targets in Syria.

The United States has already been training and arming Iraqi national forces, to the tune of more than $25 billion, with little success on the battlefield. He will now add Kurdish forces to the list of those America is aiding and intends to step up U.S. aid to Syrian moderate forces, who have also been unsuccessful to date, if Washington can figure out who among the Syrian opposition are the moderates.

Mr. Obama hopes to find allies to form a coalition of the willing to fight the Islamic State. This also presents problems.

Advertise with us

The most fervent enemies of the Islamic State are President Bashar al-Assad’s government in Syria and the Iranian Shiite regime of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, neither of which are comfortable allies for the United States, except in the sense that the enemy of my enemy is my friend. America’s usual Middle East partners are Saudi Arabia and the Persian Gulf states, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. The problem is that these states, and Jordan, another linchpin in Mr. Obama’s purported game plan, are Sunni states and mortally terrified of the Islamic State extremists. Money from citizens of these states in fact finances in part the Islamic State.

Secretary of State John Kerry has been given the job of trying to square this circle of Middle East perfidy, getting the Sunni states that host the extreme Muslims who finance the Islamic State to support the U.S.-led effort to “degrade and ultimately destroy” it, in Mr. Obama’s words.

It is hard to imagine that the American president would set himself, and his country, a task that he must know is likely to fail. It is equally hard to see why, after having promised as a candidate in 2008 to end the Iraq war, he would now be adding U.S. forces to another round in that country and expanding the U.S. part of the war to Syria, particularly when prospects for success are as dismal as they are.

Meet the Editorial Board