Only a day after the state Insurance Department released the transition plan on the coming UPMC-Highmark separation, the two health care giants were sniping at each other again.

The occasion was the lawsuit filed Wednesday by Highmark against UPMC over alleged “pricing manipulation” that Highmark said has led to $300 million in overbilling for cancer-related treatment at UPMC facilities in the last four years.

The gist of Highmark’s complaint is that UPMC engages in “upcoding,” changing the facility type where the treatment is provided from a doctor’s office to a hospital outpatient center. Because a hospital is more specialized, sophisticated and costly, it can bill at a higher rate. Yet in these cases, according to the lawsuit, patients received their oncology care in physicians’ offices merely affiliated with a hospital.

A UPMC spokesman fired back that Highmark’s own hospitals, in the new Allegheny Health Network, have engaged in the same kind of billing and that Highmark, by going to court, is breaching its agreement with UPMC to settle billing disputes through arbitration.

Advertise with us

Whatever the outcome of this case and regardless of how many hospital networks practice upcoding, the accounting maneuver is disingenuous and makes health care unnecessarily costly for patients, insurers and the nation. It’s similar to the case of an O’Hara man we highlighted on Wednesday in which a 20-minute exam in his dermatologist’s office resulted in two bills — one from the doctor and one from the UPMC hospital five miles away.

The use of such billing practices — and the federal rules that may permit them — are worth close scrutiny by the state attorney general or at a congressional hearing. Health care systems should be able to cover their costs, but not by gouging the public.

Meet the Editorial Board.