The about-face of Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist on stem-cell research has repercussions and implications on a range of levels. The first question is which Bill Frist was foremost in the decision: the doctor, the Republican majority leader, the political conservative or the potential 2008 presidential candidate?

The idea of Sen. Frist as a doctor is, in general, comforting to Americans. Rightly or wrongly, they presume that doctors operate on a higher ethical level and that physicians who are also politicians think and make decisions not just as campaign finance magnets but as people who have the citizens' best interests at heart.

Within that context lies the best interpretation of the Tennessee Republican's change of position: as a doctor he realized the value of human embryonic stem cell research and that he could not be opposed to it.

Sen. Frist, as a doctor-politician, has had occasional lapses from grace -- notably, his instant, long-distance, wrong analysis in the Terri Schiavo case -- but it is hard to imagine someone as intelligent as he not understanding the importance of proceeding with stem-cell research.

Advertise with us

As Republican Senate majority leader, the problem for Sen. Frist is that his new position puts him at odds with President Bush. But then Mr. Bush is not a doctor and so apparently cannot be expected to agree with Dr. Frist's -- or former First Lady Nancy Reagan's -- position on stem-cell research, nor keep quiet on "intelligent design," nor keep private his view on a multimillion-dollar athlete's use of steroids.

Sen. Frist's credentials as a political conservative were certainly damaged by the position he has now taken on stem-cell research. Some of them have ripped into him publicly. He has not been invited to speak at this weekend's second round of "Justice Sunday," the religious right's rant on how the parts of the U.S. government the Republicans control -- the White House and the two houses of Congress -- should clamp down on what they don't own yet, the judiciary.

Sen. Frist may be better off not associated with Justice Sunday II. Television evangelist Pat Robertson's latest counsel to his followers asks them to pray for more vacancies on the Supreme Court.

Finally, where stands Sen. Frist's potential quest for the Republican nomination for the presidency in the wake of all this? We would have to say that, on balance, it probably helps him. If one stacks up the number of voters who are -- or have relatives or friends who may be -- potential victims of the diseases that stem-cell research can help to cure, they probably outnumber substantially those on the religious right who find such medical research repugnant to their beliefs.

We like the idea that Dr. Frist did not make a fine political accounting in taking his position, but that, instead, he acted in accordance with his principles as a doctor, dedicated to healing. In that framework, he did right.