For four years, members of the flock of the former St. John Vianney Church in Allentown have lobbied the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh to buy the structure, which held its last Mass in 2016.

The group formed the St. George Church Preservation Society — using the church’s original name — and began fundraising.

Bob Kress, a group leader, said members want to restore it as a Catholic chapel for occasional Masses, weddings, funerals and a weekly worship service.

“There is interest in tours, concerts and inspirational speakers,” he said. “We would provide a space for the food pantry to move back into the church and also store and archive memorabilia of the St. George family and the Allentown community.”

Advertise with us

Every entreaty of the group to the diocese has been rebuffed.

When the church was closed, Mr. Kress said, “the decree of the bishop indicated that it could not be cared for.” It was the last of four churches closed in the St. John Vianney parish.

“We say we will care for it,” Mr. Kress said. “We had to use the appeal process to defer demolition. That process has now led to the ‘supreme court’ at the Vatican, and we are waiting for a decision on our proposal.”

He estimates it would cost about $600,000 to restore the church. The group has pledges to cover one-fourth of the cost.

The Rev. Nicholas Vaskov, a spokesman for the diocese, said that, because the bishop’s decision is being appealed, he cannot discuss how much the diocese might agree to sell the church for.

Advertise with us

He said he was not familiar with the details of the discussion with the preservation society, “but I can tell you that it can’t be a Catholic church if the diocese doesn’t maintain it. It would have to be reduced to profane, but not sordid, use” to be reused for any reason.

“We don’t have priest resources,” Father Vaskov said. “How do you maintain a church without a priest?”

That’s a pretty clear-cut answer, but it is not the answer the St. George society has gotten, or, if it has, the members are not satisfied.

“If we had $750,000, I think they’d think twice,” Mr. Kress said.

He said he is puzzled the diocese would prefer to spend millions to remove all the sacred items and demolish the building rather than sell it.

Advertise with us

The paradox is that the diocese would sell it — just not to people who are interested in delivering the Catholic message. Catholic congregations are dwindling and disappearing, to the chagrin of the top hierarchy, and yet a group that wants to keep a church a church is thwarted while a private buyer can get a great deal for nonreligious use.

Mike Fanto bought the Holy Innocents church, convent and schools in Sheraden, and said that under the deed agreement, none of the properties could be a church. Two of the five addresses could be found on the county real estate website, and they show that he paid $60,000.

He said his intention was to flip them, and they are on the market now for a package price of $595,000. He said he had interested buyers for a manuscript museum and for housing.

The St. George society has a contact list of 1,400 and about 130 members, Mr. Kress said.

“Five hundred people a year make donations. We sell T-shirts, calendars, Christmas cards. We have an annual spaghetti dinner and raise about $4,000. We have reached out to the church family all over the world. There are a lot of successful people out there who have donated.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kress, a native of Allentown who now lives in Warrendale, was once a neighborhood activist who, in the 1980s, lobbied for a grocery store, which has since closed, and to retain the trolley tracks for possible future use. He went to the St. George high school, and his devoted family, like most devoted church members, believed it was their church.

Everyone knows the flock is not in charge, but to lose every remnant after such tremendous generational buy-in is tantamount to root shock. The faithful give their time, volunteering for fish fries, festivals and other fundraisers. They worship and tithe, sometimes beyond their means, and they feel they should have some stake, some say in what happens to their beloved church.

“Just think if we can reach an agreement and put out the word to the St. George family: ‘We have a deal! We have saved your mother’s church, the church you were baptized in,’” Mr. Kress said.

Just think.

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.