America set itself up to nurture the rogues, the bullies and lost souls who have become our homegrown terrorists.
The origins of America’s vision were enmeshed in violence — from taking the land of native tribes to taking Africans from their land and enslaving them. This country has been violent all over the world through most of our history. In few cases were we right to.
But Americans don’t protest. The exception was a sustained outcry during the war in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia.
We seem to accept violence as a state of the union. We have rallies and vigils, but they are one and done. It is impractical to hold them every day.
I was inspired to write this because of a mass murder that was on an inside page of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette recently — five people killed in a bank in Florida. A friend on Facebook expressed dismay that we no longer are moved by these mass shootings.
Five dead isn’t enough to trigger our shock anymore. But no matter how many are killed, our shock fades quickly.
Read More
The closer to home it hits, the longer the grip of sorrow lasts, but society’s collective response has become like a wavelength, with crests of shock for multiple-victim shootings and troughs to recover in time for the next one.
The Second Amendment was written when men carried muskets. I’m not making a point against modern weapons, per se. The First Amendment was written when “the press” was a slow and cumbersome thing that looked like a cross between a gutted armoire and a torture device. It was used back then mostly for pamphlets and books. That “the press” can now include television airheads yacking premonitions about figures in the news for ratings means that arms for self-defense can include AR-15s.
The men who carried the muskets were fresh from the grip of tyranny, and they were fierce to defend against reprisal. They needed to defend themselves as they pushed westward. And they wanted guns to keep slaves from rebelling.
For any and all reasons it was written, the Second Amendment guarantees that America will be weaponized in perpetuity.
I am in favor of the Second Amendment — every single word of it. But it will never be fully honored because a well-regulated militia would depend on politicians to reclaim their moral souls.
If we truly accept that — oh, well, it’s a violent world and there’s nothing we can do about it — we would stop reacting in horror to mass violence. This may be where we are now, what my Facebook friend has hit on.
Over and over again, our “leaders” spout dreck and dribble in fake sorrow and vow that something must be done “so that a tragedy like this never happens again!” Only to acknowledge that, hey, it’s a violent world.
Yet we could reform ourselves. We have reformed so much bad practice over our history. The South kicked and screamed against reform, but it is no longer a terrorist state. Women can vote and own land and do almost any work they choose.
Back when smokers outnumbered nonsmokers, the public and policy makers took on the powerful tobacco industry. Miracle of miracles, smoking rates plummeted.
Over the past half-century, we made so much progress cleaning up our polluted land and water. We’re on the verge of ceding that progress, but I trust that most of us value a clean and healthy environment and will insist that we not regress. At least not too much.
We are likely to look back, 10 years from now, and say, “Can you believe we used to put people in jail for marijuana?”
We had the will to put men on the moon. No one defeated that dream by saying, “Where are we going to get the money?”
We could have both the will and the money to ensure that all Americans get all the health care they need at little or no cost. The cost of our military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for a year should cover that.
You and I are paying for the Pentagon’s scandalously padded budget with no resistance. Why would we resist ensured medical care for each other?
We could become less violent and less accepting of violence, but that would be the most entrenched and resistant bad behavior we would ever take on, considering the pain that was inflicted and suffered in the birth and growth of our nation.
If violence is how you get what you want, it is the only way you know how to keep it.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.