It is a travesty that I cannot exercise my First Amendment rights without infringement. This is America. I have the God-given right to walk into a crowded theater and falsely yell “FIRE!”
If you hinder my right to do that, you create a slippery slope. Where will it end?
* * *
Does this argument make sense to anyone?
Yet this is the First Amendment equivalent of opposition to sensible conditions placed on the Second Amendment. It will probably take a court case to get them, like the 1919 case that placed a limit on speech that threatens the greater good.
But some people think we are at a tipping point toward a new day for the Second Amendment in the court of legislative opinion — triggered by the activism of teenagers whose school in Parkland, Fla., became a bloodbath almost a month ago.
Read More
That activism has spawned more activism. Locally, students at the Pittsburgh Creative and Performing Arts School (6-12), or CAPA, Downtown, have gone on a rampage of letter writing to Pennsylvania’s U.S. senators, more than 100 letters pleading for sensible gun controls.
The Rev. Randy Bush, senior pastor of the East Liberty Presbyterian Church — with whom I have had conversations over the years about the dictates of a moral society, the rights of mankind and other light topics — informed me that after the Parkland shootings, his daughter became pensive. She had turned 17 that day.
“We were talking and she started crying,” he said. “She expressed the real fear of going to school and not knowing if it was the last time she would see us.
“When I dropped her off at school, ‘She said, ‘I love you,’ and it sounded distinctive.”
Charlotte Bush then became purposeful, proposing to her teachers and fellow students that they should target U.S. Sens. Bob Casey and Pat Toomey in a letter-writing campaign for gun controls.
One student, arguing against arming teachers, wrote that she lives in a neighborhood where she “wakes up to gunshots. I can’t attend a school where that fear continues to take over my body as soon as I walk through the metal detectors. Guns don’t belong where children learn. …”
Another wrote that “… not one teacher decided to go into their profession in hopes to possess a firearm.”
Besides asking for a ban on bump stocks and better background checks, one student wrote, “No teenager should own any gun. In teenage years, you are going through much stress and emotional change. This can cause very sporadic decisions and ideas.”
Rev. Bush has activated his own sense of urgency to keep the momentum up and pressure on.
“On this topic, we cannot be deflected or deferred,” he said regarding arguments such as “It’s not guns; it’s parenting,” “It’s not guns; it’s mental health,” “It’s not guns; it’s failures of security,” or “You’re politicizing this issue,” and, my personal favorite, “Now is not the time to talk about gun control.”
Rev. Bush said he wanted to support the teenagers with “a faith response.”
On Wednesday — the one-month anniversary of the massacre in Parkland — he and other clergy will gather outside the church from 9:45 to 10:15 a.m. for “a time of remembrance, one half-hour to remember and not lose the energy, to speak out for universal background checks, a ban on weapons of war,” he said. “We can fine-tune these ideas and listen” to the opposition, “but we will no longer tolerate blanket refusals. Those days are over.
“To make this a public health crisis is imperative, to move it out of the realm of me versus you. We know what’s right. We just have to do it.”
The students from Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School have been so inspiring that the Florida Legislature — home of Marion Hammer, the National Rifle Association’s all-powerful, all-seeing, unelected articulator of legislation — recently passed restrictions banning bump stocks and requiring a three-day wait for background checks, among other measures.
If Florida can do this, every state can do this. And if every state does this, we will no longer have to plead in vain for our invertebrate members of Congress to do something.
It won’t be long before our activist teenagers become the voting block that could make America civilized again.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.