It has been almost 15 years since a master plan set a course for restoring Allegheny Commons Park, the city’s oldest, on the North Side. The Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy and its partners have held a series of public meetings to share design ideas and get feedback to update the plan. The third was last week.

The march of restoration from east to west has been as slow as fundraising for big-ticket projects can be. One eastern-most swath has been restored in two phases. The crown jewel is in the next phase — replacement of a circular flower bed with a fountain to replicate the original fountain.

The price tag of $2.8 million includes a maintenance endowment. The campaign has raised $2 million so far.

A bid is expected to be chosen this week and a contract signed next month, with groundbreaking in the spring if the stars align. That phase will literally turn the corner from Cedar onto North Avenue. Westward ho!

Advertise with us

The conservancy has surveyed park users and gotten almost 500 responses.

“Their priorities lined up with priorities identified by our focus groups,” said the conservancy’s parks curator, Susan Rademacher.

Here are a few of the many ideas that have emerged so far: an inventory of trees and tree health; more diversity of lawn seeds; a canopy of lower trees beneath the old ones for richer and healthier habitats; improved lighting and paths; wetland plantings; monument restoration with informational signs; drinking fountains, more benches and litter cans; replacement of the much-missed pedestrian bridge over the railroad tracks; and renovation of the 1930s stone restroom building by the tennis courts.

New construction would include restrooms at the ball fields, a family-size shelter for picnics in the park’s southwest corner — which existed in the park’s early days — and a lakeside pavilion with cafe, restrooms and an event terrace.

Discussions at the last meeting highlighted the challenge of preserving in the 21st-century a park created in the 19th. Several neighbors suggested new uses for underused areas while others questioned the addition of things that weren’t originally there.

Advertise with us

Holding fast to the 19th-century character of anything is nearly impossible and may not be wise if it negates what we know and if we fail to solve problems in the process. Park restoration always provides opportunity for stormwater management.

“You can incorporate techniques for sustainability in a historic setting,” said Fred Bonci of LaQuatra Bonci architects, “you just have to be more subtle.”

LaQuatra Bonci is a partner on this project, with consultants in historic preservation, hydrology and social innovation.

Allegheny Commons Park was established in 1867. It is a on the city’s list of historic sites and the National Register of Historic Places, but it has been much-altered over the years. It was home to a penitentiary, a forerunner of the Phipps Conservancy and, today, the National Aviary — all on the same rough footprint.

When the lights in the park work, they are generated electrically. Electricity wasn’t original to the park. When bathing suits were modest bathing costumes, Lake Elizabeth was natural, much larger and fronted by a boathouse. In the 1960s, that portion of the park was dramatically altered by a Modernist design, abbreviating the lake’s size and depth, hemming it in with a short wall that people can sit on if they check first for goose poop.

Advertise with us

That design, the work of Simonds & Simonds, has itself become a historic piece. Preservationists in the ’60s might have been appalled, but it was allowed to happen. Of all the horrible things that happened in the 1960s, that was not one of them. It provided a 19th-century park with another dimension, another texture in the mid-20th.

It’s not certain whether areas of the park that get muddy and boggy now got muddy and boggy in the early days, but my guess is that’s an original problem. The solution for naturally wet areas is to create healthy wetland environments for them.

Would that violate the historic character? Would it violate the Modernist design to deepen Lake Elizabeth, give it a natural bed and allow plants to grow in it to keep it cleaner? Could that irony add to the historic fabric?

These are questions many of us left the meeting with, and all are worthy of debate. We can all agree that plenty of time exists for that. The action plan being finalized after the fourth planning meeting in March likely will be updated years from now.

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.