Donald Trump, president of the United States, meet Pyrrhus, king of Epirus. The leader of the great military force and industrial powerhouse of 2026 who went to war with mighty bombers, missiles and drones might gain some pointed perspective from the third century B.C.E. Hellenic warrior whose military entourage included 20 elephants.

He is known in history for saying, “If we are victorious in one more battle with the Romans, we shall be utterly ruined” and for giving his name to the idea of a “Pyrrhic victory.”

Who won the Iran war? And was it a Pyrrhic victory? Who has the stronger hand in the bargaining that now is following the Islamabad sessions?

Who won?

Is it the Americans, who bombarded the country into rubble and submission, while not nearly ending Persian civilization but still striking a decisive blow against it? “We’ve defeated them militarily,” Mr. Trump said.

Advertise with us

Or is it the Iranians, who have realized the power of their geographical position along the northern coastline of the Strait of Hormuz and who not only survived the onslaught but survived to fight another day?

The United States partially depleted its stores of military equipment yet still retains scores of military options, although there is almost no eagerness outside of Israel, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s Pentagon suite and some MAGA pockets to employ them.

For its part, Iran still has a large supply of ballistic missiles and launchers, a supple base for the manufacture of drones, and a devoted elite core of the militant Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.

Plus this: Iran’s technological team assigned with the task of producing them, the knowledge of how to manufacture them and perhaps even the raw materials to create them, may remain much the way they were before the war began.

“There’s no victory unless the other side is willing to give up,” said Margaret MacMillan, the University of Toronto historian considered the leading authority on war and post-war negotiations. “The Americans never lost a battle in Vietnam, but North Vietnam won the war; it was the Americans who pulled out. Vladimir Putin won many battles at the beginning of the Ukraine war but hasn’t won the war.”

Advertise with us

Both countries possess strains of willingness and reluctance to recommence the battling.

Despite the absence of credible public-opinion surveys, Iranians actually might be more willing to return to battle. But an immeasurable slice of the battered Iranian population, especially the opponents of the Tehran theocracy who only months ago thronged the streets in protest, are surely weary of the toll of battle.

Some elements of the Trump team, likely including Mr. Hegseth, may be eager to fight. At the same time, most Democrats, many mainstream Republicans, and part of the isolationist wing of the MAGA movement oppose new military engagement.

The war weakened Trump

The moral high ground that Mr. Trump occupied in his determination to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons now has been leveled. His vow to destroy Iranian civilization won the contempt of global leaders from Pope Leo XIV to backbenchers in the House of Representatives. Several MAGA luminaries have fled the movement’s umbrella.

Democrats on Capitol Hill have revived talk of impeaching Mr. Trump for a third time. The Republican hold on both houses of Congress has been weakened, if not broken.

Advertise with us

“His comments on things, especially about the pope, have hurt him and the United States, said Roberto D’Alimonte, a political scientist at the University of Florence. “The war has alienated many of America’s friends.”

There is little question that the war has weakened Mr. Trump at home as well.

Inflation hit a two-year peak. Gasoline prices may go down, but they are months from returning to the pre-war position when the president could claim that they were at astonishing lows. Indeed, overall energy prices in the U.S. are 12.5% higher year over year, with fuel oil marking a stunning 44.2% rise.

Concerned about his poll ratings, troubled about Republican prospects in this fall’s midterm congressional elections, frustrated that he did not win the swift victory he predicted in his “little excursion” in the Middle East, and furious at Iran’s intransigence at Islamabad, Mr. Trump lashed out with an announcement of a naval blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. Blockades generally are considered acts of war.

On the surface the United States has unstoppable force. But it has learned that Iran is an unmovable object.

Advertise with us

Consider this remark issued by Iran’s foreign ministry after the Pakistani summit: “The heavy loss of our great elders, dear ones, and fellow countrymen has made our response to pursue the Iranian nation’s interests and rights firmer than ever before.”

That does not meet Professor MacMillan’s standard.

Making war, making peace

But it is a reminder of the wisdom of Georges Clemenceau, the French prime minister who was a force at the Versailles peace negotiations at the end of World War I. “It is easier to make war than make peace,” he said in his July 1919 Speech on Peace in Verdun, the site of the war’s longest battle of the war and 800,000 casualties.

Four months after that speech, he told the French Senate, in words that have eerie application today, “I do not know whether war is an interlude in peace or whether peace is an interlude in war.”

David M. Shribman’s previous column was “What has the war in Iran changed?”.