When President Donald Trump ordered an armada of naval vessels, fighter planes, bombers and high-tech surveillance drones to the Middle East, he thought he had the answer to decades of tension and terrorism from Iran. He may well be right.
But with that answer comes a series of supplemental questions. All require deeper thought than Mr. Trump — like Ronald Reagan, motivated by instinct — customarily is credited for. And all require answers in the next few days or weeks.
Here are some of them.
What will the president say?
• The Paul Simon conundrum. In his classic “50 Ways to Leave Your Lover,” the great singer-songwriter wrote, “Make a new plan, Stan.” In this case, Mr. Trump needs to make a first plan, or if he has one, to make public his first one or his current one.
There is, of course, merit for Mr. Trump to have a private or secret plan. It keeps his opponents in Tehran guessing, probably to some advantage for the president and for American forces.
But the Simon line goes: “Don’t be coy, Roy.” Mr. Trump can’t be coy with the American people. If he has a plan, he hasn’t made it clear. He hasn’t shared his vision for the new Iran or for the new power calculus in the Middle East.
• The Ben E. King conundrum. He’s the singer-songwriter who wrote “Stand By Me,” and in there is a lesson for Mr. Trump: “I won’t be afraid/ Just as long as you stand, stand by me.”
Right now Americans are not standing by their president. Poll results show skepticism, if not outright opposition, to this military engagement in Iran. That’s a dramatic break from American tradition, perhaps as a consequence of the Trump second term itself being a dramatic break from American tradition.
In World War II, Korea, Vietnam, even the first Gulf War, Americans initially rallied behind their president. Not this time. The reason: See above.
What will Congress do?
• The James Madison conundrum. As the principal author of the Constitution, this founding father helped shape the delicate balance of power and the separation of powers in the new American government. The war power was given to Congress in an ambiguous, confusing and often frustrating fashion.
Mr. Trump didn’t go to Congress for permission to initiate hostilities against Iran, as George W. Bush did before sending U.S. troops into Iraq in 2003. Democrats and a handful of Republicans brought War Powers Resolution measures to the floor of both the Senate and the House earlier this month and both failed.
But those were efforts to stop U.S. military action, not — a subtle difference but a critical one — to approve of it. Every parent knows the difference between giving permission and tolerating something already underway.
Mr. Trump no doubt will point to those narrow “victories” on Capitol Hill as more than forbearance, but permission. That’s what Lyndon Johnson did with the 1964 Bay of Tonkin Resolution, which passed overwhelmingly. He said it was “like grandma’s nightshirt — it covered everything.” The defeat of War Powers Resolution efforts to stop the Iran war is the grandma’s nightshirt of the 21st century.
• The U.S. Grant conundrum. The Civil War general became known as “Unconditional Surrender” Grant. The current president might be regarded as Unconditional Surrender Trump.
That’s because Mr. Trump, employing a phrase without thinking of its historical meaning or its consequences, has called for the unconditional surrender of Iran. Abraham Lincoln embraced the notion with care but with enthusiasm. Franklin Roosevelt did so, at the Casablanca summit of 1943, but not to punish the citizens of the Axis nations but destroy “the philosophies ... based on conquest and the subjugation of other people.”
Mr. Trump has made that point but likely has not thought through what unconditional surrender might entail — for example, American troops on the ground in Iran. The unconditional surrender of Japan was followed by seven years of American occupation, which brings us to the next question.
Where will MAGA go?
• The Arthur Vandenberg conundrum. Sen. Vandenberg started out as one of the leading voices for American isolationism and after World War II became a prominent spokesman for American engagement.
Mr. Trump is a gyroscope who can spin in any direction. But much of his MAGA movement was drawn into it in large measure because of its isolationist tint, its skepticism of nation-building, its resistance to “forever wars.”
MAGA’s future after Mr. Trump is uncertain. But its role and profile in the remaining two and a half years of Mr. Trump’s presidency is an important element of contemporary politics and will shape its response to the vacuum Mr. Trump creates when he leaves office in January 2029.
That’s why the MAGA response to the Iran (and Venezuelan and perhaps to an imminent Cuban) invasion is so critical. It will shape the destiny of what is arguably the most potent and most important bloc in American politics today.
Mr. Trump’s pick-one approach to having multiple objectives in Iran makes it easier for shards of his movement to pick one element (say, nation-building) and to break away for that reason. With so many objections, there are so many ways for that to happen.
David M. Shribman’s previous column was “The U.S. has triggered total war — and is getting lost in the fog of war.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.