MONTREAL — We know their names. Some of them are Margaret “Pearl” Fraser, Mary Agnes McKenzie, Carola Douglas, Alexina Dussault, Margaret Fortescue, Minnie Follette. For more than a century, and to this day, Canadians have mourned the death of 14 nursing sisters who on June 27, 1918, survived a submarine attack on the British hospital ship Llandovery Castle, only to perish when the German U-boat circled back to sink the lifeboats, reportedly to kill the witnesses to the crew’s sinking of a hospital ship, a violation of their own navy’s standing orders.
The episode so outraged Canadians that Brigadier General George Tuxford, a former homesteader from Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, cited two Moose Jaw nurses in his instructions that his men’s battle cry should be “Llandovery Castle” — words that “should be the last to ring in the ears of the Hun as the bayonet was driven home.”
We don’t know the names of the two men who clung to the wrecked refuse of a doomed boat in the Caribbean when American personnel, engaged in battle against people considered drug traffickers, followed instructions — no one knows for sure how high up those orders originated — to kill them.
In its defense of the decision, the government agency still known formally as the Defense Department has reopened a debate that dates directly to the Llandovery Castle and that has been considered settled since the Nuremberg Trials following the Holocaust and the end of World War II.
The issue
That issue: whether military personnel are required to carry out orders to perform duties that are illegal.
This issue may seem simple, morally and legally. The Pentagon’s law-of-war manual prohibits “hostilities on the basis that there shall be no survivors.”
The moral implications are clear. The legal ones are a little murky on account of a subtlety in the reality of the definition of war. In this case, no formal declaration of war against Venezuela or Venezuelan drug traffickers having been voted by both houses of Congress. The action the American military personnel carried out may be a crime, but it is not a war crime.
That does not exonerate those who issued the command, but it may insulate them from the specific charge — being tossed around Washington today like unpinned grenades — of having issued orders that come under the category of a war crime.
“The material conditions for an armed conflict between the United States and these drug traffickers simply does not exist,” Robert Goldman, director of the War Crimes Research Office at American University’s Washington College of Law, said in an interview. “There are no combatants where there is no armed conflict. They are attacking and summarily executing civilians, and that is prohibited by human rights law.”
Mr. Goldman and Democratic Rep. Seth Moulton of Massachusetts, a Marine Corps combat veteran of four tours in Iraq, both told me the action in the Caribbean wasn’t war but was — their word, not prompted by me — “murder.” Many Democrats and some Republicans, calling for congressional investigations, seem to lean to agreeing.
The debate
But what remains to be determined, and what has been unresolved since the 1973 approval of the War Powers Act over President Richard Nixon’s veto, is how much reasonable leeway a president has in engaging military force. That debate won’t be resolved in this case or perhaps ever.
The editorial board of the Wall Street Journal, no nest of leftists, put the matter succinctly: “Our view is that the Commander in Chief deserves legal latitude as part of his constitutional war powers. But that doesn’t extend to shooting the wounded in violation of U.S. and international rules of war.”
They then expressed worry that “such excesses will also turn the public against allowing a President the power he may someday need to defend the country’s interests quickly.”
The debate over this incident will not die quickly, especially because a group of Democrats warned military personnel not to carry out illegal orders.
Mr. Trump accused them of “SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR,” wrote that “Each one of these traitors to our Country should be ARRESTED AND PUT ON TRIAL,” added that their action was “punishable by DEATH!” The Pentagon is threatening to recall to active duty Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona to have him tried in a military court.
Unknown as I write: whether Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth issued the order to fire on the survivors or whether it came directly from Admiral Frank Bradley of Special Operations Command.
The verdict
In its ruling at the Leipzig war-crimes Llandovery Castle trial, the German Supreme Court said firing on the life boats was an “offense against the law of nations,” arguing that “in war at sea, the killing of shipwrecked people who have taken refuge in lifeboats is forbidden.”
It added, in a sentiment that would have important implications after the Holocaust, “A subordinate obeying [an] order is liable to punishment if it was known to him that the order of the superior involved the infringement of civil or military law.”
None of this is simple. But this argument from the German court echoes through the years: “The killing of defenseless shipwrecked people is an act in the highest degree contrary to ethical principles.”
David M. Shribman’s previous column was “American politics: Where ignorant armies clash.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.