The citizenship test is an easy exam. Fifth-grade students could ace it at the end of their year of rudimentary history instruction. Now the administration want to toughen the test. They are contemplating an essay requirement that they say will give indications of applicants’ “moral character.”

A memo released last month by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services speaks of an effort to achieve “a holistic assessment of an alien’s behavior, adherence to societal norms, and positive contributions that affirmatively demonstrate good moral character.”

The irony is that the citizenship test is full of questions that are top of mind in the country’s politics in this fraught era. Its prescribed answers are technically true, but only if one doesn’t go any deeper. For example:

What does the Constitution say?

What is the supreme law of the land? The government offers only one answer: the Constitution.

Advertise with us

This is pretty straight forward, but what the Constitution means is subject to interpretation, and to fevered debate. The applicant for citizenship won’t be asked, for example, whether the Second Amendment language of the “right to bear arms” refers to a militia or to an individual.

What stops one branch of government from becoming too powerful? Every American schoolchild knows the answer to this one. The study guide for citizenship applicants sets out the two acceptable answers: checks and balances and the separation of powers.

No problem — until we get to their implementation. How these two easily understood concepts are applied to the actual functioning of government isn’t quite so clear. The Supreme Court under the Franklin Delano Roosevelt and Richard Nixon administrations reined in the executive branch.

The legislative branch in the Nixon years stymied the executive branch when Congress passed the War Powers Act of 1973 (meant to restrain presidential discretion in military operations) and the Impoundment Control Act of 1974 (which required congressional approval for the rescission of funds) — two areas that have become areas of contention in the past eight months.

Indeed, at the heart of this seemingly uncomplicated question is its application to contemporary politics. Powers that are separate and that provide checks on other branches of government are relevant only if they are engaged.

Advertise with us

In the past several months, the legislative branch hasn’t chosen to check the power of the executive, but it also hasn’t asserted its right to assert its prerogatives as a means of preserving its separateness from the executive — something the Republicans may wish they had done the next time a Democrat is president.

A generation ago, Democratic senator Robert Byrd of West Virginia deliberately asserted congressional authority in the face of actions of a president of his own party, Jimmy Carter, in the matter of the president’s unilateral suspension of 19 congressionally authorized water projects.

What does the law require?

What is the “rule of law”? A concept with origins in Ancient Greece, this term emerged at the beginning of the 17th century, growing out of criticism of British royal economic regulations. It’s perhaps the fundamental element of American civic life.

The government study guide provides three acceptable answers, each with challenges in our age:

Government must obey the law, a concept tested by the deployment of federal troops in American cities that may violate a 19th-century law prohibiting the use of the military forces to enforce civilian law.

Advertise with us

No one is above the law, a precept constantly cited by presidents but often jeopardized by presidents. Richard Nixon, in his post-presidential interview with David Frost, said, “When the president does it, that means it is not illegal.” Mr. Trump, at a cabinet meeting last month, said, “I have the right to do anything I want to do.”

Leaders must obey the law, a notion tested by the recent detainment and deportation of student protesters and foreign scholars. (A separate question in the citizenship test asks: “Under our Constitution, some powers belong to the states. What is one power of the states?” One prescribed answer: “provide protection (police).”)

What can the president do?

Who is in charge of the executive branch? The answer here is simple: “the president.” The implications of that answer are not simple. In recent months a consequential debate has unfolded over the Constitution’s Article II language stating “the executive Power shall be vested in a President.”

Questions about the “unitary theory of the executive” that empowers the president have swirled around government circles for four decades. George W. Bush employed it in matters of executive privilege and the creation of various “czars” for specific policy areas. But only this year has this theory entered broad public discussion.

Proponents argue the Founders saw the president as the supreme figure of the executive branch, thus providing broad powers over departments and agencies. Opponents argue, as Syracuse University law professor David Driesen put it in a 2021 University of California Law Journal article, that “centralization of head-of-state control over the executive branch provides a pathway to autocracy.”

Advertise with us

In days following Sen. Robert Byrd’s complaint about Mr. Carter’s water-project cancellations, conservative-leaning Democratic Sen. J. Bennett Johnston of Louisiana denounced “government by executive.” This matter is a test not only for citizenship applicants — but also for the government itself.

David M. Shribman’s previous column was “Unfortunately for him, Rudy Giuliani will always be Rudy Giuliani.”