In the age of Trump — a decade-long epoch that began in 2015 — several serious, high-profile books have been written about presidential character. None of the three published in the last 15 months explicitly takes on the difficult question of evaluating the character of Donald Trump.
All three — one rooted in the life of Abraham Lincoln, one in the presidency of George H.W. Bush, the third focused more generally on modern presidents — speak of the glittering yet tarnished character of Mr. Trump’s presidential predecessors.
But the implicit message, intended or not, is clear.
Flawed characters
Previous presidents, to be sure, have had manifest and manifold character flaws: marital infidelity for Warren G. Harding, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, and Bill Clinton; financial finagling in the example of Mr. Johnson and maybe Joseph R. Biden Jr.; lies about their medical fitness for office in the case of Woodrow Wilson and Mr. Biden; general mendacity in virtually every president, including that of Jimmy Carter, a Baptist deacon who pledged he “would not tell a lie.”
But amid American presidents, Mr. Trump’s character stands alone, vulnerable to the charges of infidelity, finagling, and a quality of mendacity that is without equal. Indeed, he prompts comparison with Lincoln’s description of his great rival, Senator Stephen A. Douglas, whom he said could “tell a lie to 10,000 people one day even though he knows he may have to deny it to 5,000 the next.”
But the purpose of this column is not to catalogue Mr. Trump’s flaws. It is to examine the nature of presidential character and the notion, advanced by both Franklin Roosevelt and Mr. Kennedy, that life in the White House is less likely to create character than to reveal it.
This is no easy exercise. And so in Allen C. Guelzo’s “Our Ancient Faith: Lincoln, Democracy, and the American Faith,” in Jean Becker’s “Character Matters: And Other Life Lessons from George H.W. Bush,” and in Mark K. Updegrove’s “Make Your Mark: Lessons in Character from Seven Presidents,” we see the complexity in this question.
President Johnson is a good example of the difficulties the character question presents. Crude in public, he spoke meanly of the “man on the streets” who only “wants a little medical care, a rug on the floor, a picture on the wall.” He employed various colorful pronunciations of the N-word. He made crude remarks about women.
Men with visions
But he still was able to imagine a Great Society of justice and prosperity. He was able to say in his 1965 Inaugural Address, “For this is what America is all about. It is the uncrossed desert and the unclimbed ridge. It is the star that is not reached and the harvest sleeping in the unplowed ground.”
And he was able to vow, two months later in a Capitol speech campaigning for the Voting Rights Act, “I want to be the president who educated young children to the wonders of their world. I want to be the president who helped to feed the hungry and to prepare them to be taxpayers instead of tax eaters. I want to be the president who helped the poor to find their own way and who protected the right of every citizen to vote in every election.”
Sometimes presidential character is found in the least pretentious presidents. Speaking of Gerald Ford, Mr. Updegrove, former director of the Lyndon Baines Johnson Library and Museum, wrote, “[T]hrough his sheer decency and instinct to do right for the sake of the country, Ford elegantly fit his moment in history.” Then he added, “There are times when we don’t need greatness from our presidents. There are times when goodness will do.”
In her book, Ms. Becker quotes George H.W. Bush in a letter to his children when he was chairman of the Republican National Committee during the Watergate years: “Civility will return to Washington eventually. The excesses condoned by the press will give way to reason and fair play. Personalities will change and our system will have proved that it works—more slowly than some would want — less efficiently than some would decree — but it works and gives us — even in adversity — great stability.”
And Professor Guelzo quotes Lincoln saying, “25 years ago I was a hired laborer” and later adding, “I happen temporarily to occupy this big white house.” He stood as a “living witness to how he hoped Americans would have “an open field and a fair chance for your industry, enterprise and intelligence; that you may have equal privileges in the race of life, with all; its desirable human aspirations.”
Bending the currents
During his time at the LBJ Library, Mr. Updegrove heard Barack Obama speak of how “humbling” was the presidency. “You are reminded in this great democracy that you are but a relay swimmer in the currents of history, bound by decisions of those who came before, relying on the efforts of those who follow to fully vindicate your vision,” he said. “But the presidency also affords a unique opportunity to bend those currents.”
Today those currents are being bent, and the current president is refusing to be a relay swimmer, instead preferring to create his own currents of history. The question Mr. Trump, who is not a reflective man, must confront is whether the presidents who follow will vindicate his vision. Addressing that is an essential element of presidential character.
David M. Shribman’s previous column was “Whose history will Americans want to hear next July 4th?”.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.