An aggressive administration fires federal employees, changes geographical names, and appoints a vaccine skeptic to high office.
Opponents of the president challenge many of his initiatives in court. The executive branch defies court orders. The House minority leader stages a sit-in on the steps of the Capitol. A Republican senator deplores his party’s ties to Wall Street and business interests. Pro-Palestinian students take over buildings and pour red paint on revered campus monuments.
This is not a moderate moment in America.
But then again, maybe it is.
The independent moderates
It sometimes seems as if the right and the left are moving farther apart than ever, at an ever-quickening pace. But there is another dynamic at work, hidden beneath the surface, overshadowed by the passions and partisanship of the country’s leaders.
Politics in the early 21st century have demonstrated the critical role those with no party identification and with moderate views are playing in our elections.
In recent elections, the party that won independent moderates won the presidential election. That means the Democrats cannot return to power unless they find a way to appeal to moderate voters. That may be difficult, when their most prominent figures today are Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who define the farthest extreme of conventional Democratic politics. (Between 35 and 45% of Democrats consider themselves moderates.)
“Small numbers of voters have been deciding presidential elections in a small number of states,” said David Brady, a Stanford political scientist. “Candidates who win the vote of moderate independents win the election. Candidates who lose those voters lose the election.”
This effect was evident in the elections of Barack Obama, Donald Trump and Joe Biden. As the Democratic presidential nominee, Mr. Obama won independent moderates by 10 percentage points in 2008 and by seven points four years later, according to The Economist/YouGov poll. In 2020, independent moderates went to Joe Biden by 8 percentage points, and he won the election.
When Democrats fail to take independent moderates, they lose. This happened in 2016, when Mr. Trump and former Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton split the independent moderates, each with 43% of that group. It happened again in 2024, when Mr. Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris each got 48% of those voters.
“In short,” said Douglas Rivers, who runs the Economist/YouGov poll, “if you win swing voters, you get elected.”
Democratic struggles
While the Democrats struggle to win the support of politically moderate Americans, the group is less critical for Republicans.
Mr. Trump has figured out the keys to the political kingdom for a Republican presidential candidate: draw substantial numbers of voters from the white working class who used to identify as Democrats and add a growing number of minorities, a formula that gives Republicans sufficient support to absorb losses in suburban areas that recently have been leaning to the Democrats.
The importance of independent moderates and Democratic moderates is not a new concept for Democrats. Winning their support has been elusive since the last quarter of the last century.
That is why the Democrats lost five of the six elections between 1968 (when Richard Nixon won the White House against Hubert Humphrey, who defined liberalism at the time despite his identification with Lyndon Johnson’s Vietnam War policy) and 1988 (when George H.W. Bush prevailed in his race against Michael Dukakis (who bore the burden of being from Brookline, Mass., perhaps the most liberal area of perhaps the most liberal state).
That prompted moderates within the party, led by Gov. Bill Clinton of Arkansas, to form the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC). Aided by running in a three-way race at a time when white working-class voters still had strong identification with the Democrats, Mr. Clinton finally broke through and captured the White House in 1992. (It is bracing to remember that Sen. Joe Biden, whose policies the Republicans pilloried as too liberal for this era, was an original member of the DLC.)
“It’s always the case that there are three conservatives to every two liberals, so the Democrats have to win moderates if they are to win elections,” Alvin From, the founder of the DLC, said in an interview. “The lesson isn’t that complicated: You have to win beyond your base when your base is too small to win.”
Competitive again
The early notion of the DLC could easily be adapted and adopted by today’s Democrats: “to develop an agenda, grounded in Democratic Party principles, that could make us competitive again in the presidential elections.”
Mr. From believes that Democrats have to be open to new faces, the way they were in 1992 — and to take on the identity of insurgents rather than establishment figures while shoring up Democratic weaknesses on the economy and crime and steering clear of identity politics. “We restored a sense of national purpose to a party that had become dominated by constituency and narrow interest groups,” he said.
Casting about for a middle ground has been a challenging chore for generations. A century and a half ago, a House of Commons friend counseled Winston Churchill, “A Middle Party … may be a very proper course when there is a Middle Party to join. Now there is none.” There isn’t one here, either.
David M. Shribman’s previous column was “One of these presidents is not gracious like the others.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.