Long before he became a Trump sycophant and a fawning aspirant for the running-mate position now occupied by Sen. JD Vance, Sen. Marco Rubio said during his campaign against Trump for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination that the Manhattan billionaire was “the most vulgar person to ever aspire to the presidency.”
Mr. Rubio was right, and the man has not changed. Publicly flinging around the F-word, for example, and expressing awe about a beloved (dead) golf champ’s private parts; urging a crowd to parrot a chant that includes a word that rhymes with “unfit.”
Trump, to be sure, has expanded the range of the politically acceptable. He also has expanded what is acceptable personally. Even in an age of raging crudity, a majority of Americans believe Trump is rude. That includes nearly a quarter of Republicans, according to a YouGov.com survey.
He’s getting worse
This element of the Trump style has become increasingly evident as the campaign slouches toward its November close. Recently he started a riff by speaking of “such a horrible four years” that the Joe Biden administration presided over, continuing: “We had a horrible — think of the — everything they touch turns to ...” The audience helpfully provided the missing word.
It didn’t help that Trump told his audience to send this message to his rival: “You have to tell Kamala Harris that you’ve had enough, that you just can’t take it anymore, we can’t stand you anymore, you’re a [expletive] vice president. The worst. You’re the worst vice president. Kamala, you’re fired. Get the hell out of here.”
Now, let it be said that Bush and Obama engaged in occasional slips into swearing. Unaware that a microphone was live, Bush used a vulgarity to describe Adam Clymer, a veteran New York Times reporter. Obama’s pre-presidential memoir includes some scatological language.
As vice president, Biden told Obama that the signing of the Affordable Care Act was, to reduce it to shorthand, a BFD. BuzzFeed has identified nearly a dozen uses of presidential vulgarity.
The reigning champion, until Trump, was Richard Nixon, for whom the phrase “expletive deleted” was invented — by his own staff. Those two words appeared scores of times in the secret Oval Office tapes that were released during the Watergate scandal.
In that gentler time (the early 1970s), a Nixon comment like this, aimed at Sen. Sam Ervin of North Carolina, the chairman of the Senate Watergate Committee, was shocking: “The president of the United States can’t be kicked around by a God-damned senile senator.” Ervin was 76, two years younger than Trump is now.
Startling language
The Nixon language startled one of his biggest allies, the Rev. Billy Graham. In an oral history recorded in 1987 for the Nixon Presidential Library, former White House chief of staff H.R. Haldeman spoke of a session with Graham and said:
“He was absolutely crushed. And he said, ‘Bob, I can’t believe what I’ve read in the tapes because ... in all the hours I spent with Richard Nixon, and there were many, many hours, he never said ‘damn,’ let alone all those things.’”
Years later, in his book “In the Arena,” published in 1990, Nixon argued that swearing was a common part of most people’s lives (“I have heard other Presidents use very earthy language in the Oval Office,” he said, presumably speaking of Harry Truman and Dwight Eisenhower). But, the disgraced 37th president explained, “Since neither I nor most other presidents had ever used profanity in public, millions were shocked” at his promiscuous employment of vulgarity — and also his crude use of ethnic slurs.
Nixon’s language was a stark contrast to that of George H.W. Bush, whom he considered as his vice-presidential selection in 1973. “President Bush perhaps swore less than anyone I ever knew,” said Jean Becker, Bush’s longtime chief of staff. She never swore in front of him and said that on the single occasion that Bush, who had a weakness for dirty jokes, uttered a single-syllable oath beginning with the letter “s,” she was astonished.
Somehow the Trump swirl of swear words — an unprecedented fusillade of vulgarity in public, not private, settings — is startling rather than shocking. The former president has broken so many barriers as candidate and chief executive that this one seems in character.
Risk in risque
Generally, etiquette experts believe that language is a sign of character. “Like actors wearing something salacious to an awards show, vulgarity is a quick way for public figures to garner attention when lacking substance,” said Jodi R.R. Smith, a manners expert who heads Mannersmith Etiquette Consulting.
But, Ms. Smith continued, “minutes of fame aren’t the same as sustained leadership. It’s the same as toddlers pitching a fit in the cereal aisle. We can hope Americans discern the difference between the quick-hit of a sugar-cereal high and the value of something of substance.”
In a close campaign like this one, there may be a risk in the risque. “Vulgarity is a misplaced sign of populism, but crass behavior seems to make a politician more relatable because he’s just as bad as we are,” said Christine Whelan, a clinical professor in the School of Human Ecology at the University of Wisconsin. “It’s still shocking when authority figures swear, but when it’s done publicly, it’s risky business.”
She’s right. Given the role of the presidency in American civic life, I swear public dignity is a bigger issue than people think.
David Shribman’s previous column was “This campaign will change America forever.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.