What Lies Beneath” is a 2000 horror film that starred Harrison Ford and Michelle Pfeiffer. In the movie, what’s unknown and unseen completely changes a couple’s lives. Today we examine what lies beneath the 2024 drama that now stars former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris.
Subterranean factors could prove the difference in the presidential election. Some lie right under the surface and are broadly recognized, such as the potential power the abortion issue might hold (advantage: Ms. Harris); the effect of the immigration issue, which the Trump team has employed in more than 100,000 television advertisements in the seven swing states (advantage: Mr. Trump); and the possibility of lengthy legal battles to determine the outcome in highly contested states (advantage: nobody but CNN, MSNBC and Fox).
The subterranean factors
Any of them could affect the outcome. But other factors lie deeper beneath the surface.
First, ballot measures. High-profile ballot measures could affect turnout, which in turn could affect results in the four states where voters will confront abortion questions. Voters, even in generally conservative places such as Kansas, have consistently backed abortion rights measures since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade and sent the question to the states.
This year abortion questions will be on the ballot of both Arizona and Nevada, both considered swing states in the 2024 election. Supporters of abortion rights will be flooding the airwaves in both states, with $13.7 million worth of ads already purchased in Arizona and another $11.9 million in Nevada.
Hardly anyone regards Florida as a swing state, but there is not only an abortion measure but also a marijuana-legalization question on the state’s ballot. It is remotely possible that those could combine to produce a surprise in Mr. Trump’s home state.
Second, the perils of polling and their effect on the Electoral College. There are growing suggestions that Mr. Trump is improving his position over 2020 in several states, including New York and six of the seven swing states. That may be inflating his national polling results, which could have the unusual effect of having him make a better showing in the popular vote but a worse showing in the Electoral College.
For years political scientists and pollsters have agreed the Electoral College provides Republicans with an advantage, which is how Mr. Trump (2016) and Mr. Bush (2000) won the election while losing the popular vote.
That may be changing. Ms. Harris’s advantage in Michigan, for example, is one-fifth as large as Joe Biden’s lead at this time. If that holds, Ms. Harris would still win Michigan and Mr. Trump would have a heftier popular vote. Applied nationally, Mr. Trump’s performance in polls could possibly suggest that the race is razor-close when it isn’t.
Then again, Mr. Trump still could lose the popular vote while winning the election. What lies beneath isn’t always easy to perceive.
Third, Trump Fatigue versus Harris Inexperience. These are two powerful forces, their effect equally unknown.
Ms. Harris didn’t serve a full Senate term and has been vice president for less than four years. Until recently, she was widely unknown. Few presidential nominees in modern history — perhaps Wendell Willkie, the business executive who was the Republican candidate in 1940 — have had such little prominence before becoming a finalist for the White House.
The Trump team is playing this card, and doing so hard. But when Richard Nixon, a fabled poker player in his Navy years, tried this gambit against John F. Kennedy in the 1960 election, it flopped. Mr. Kennedy’s innate appeal prevailed.
The Harris-is-inexperienced card, cheekily played by the only president in American history never to have won an election or served in the military, is matched by a card that the Harris campaign doesn’t even need to play. Could the election come down to the notion that the American people are simply exhausted by the chaos and contention Mr. Trump’s nine-year presence in American politics has produced?
National exhaustion
National exhaustion has been a factor at least twice in modern times. In 1920, Senator Warren G. Harding of Ohio, far less well-known than either Mr. Trump or Ms. Harris, invented a word (“normalcy”) that propelled him to the presidency. He ran against the exhaustion the American people felt after World War I and the bruising fight over American entry into the League of Nations.
Then, in 1946, when the country was exhausted from World War II, the Republicans transformed 435 separate House of Representatives and 37 Senate races into a national referendum on one question: “Had enough?” Those two words were power enough to win the GOP majorities in both chambers, picking up 56 House seats and 13 Senate seats.
There’s no question the country is exhausted. Two out of three Americans surveyed by the Pew Research Center said they were exhausted by politics—and that poll was 14 months ago. The question is whether the country’s voters are exhausted by inflation and immigration (advantage: Mr. Trump) or by bedlam and upheaval (advantage: Ms. Harris).
David Shribman’s previous column was “What story will this election tell?”
Correction: A previous version of this column misstated the state of origin of Warren G. Harding. It is Ohio.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.