Cesar Chavez was a hero of my youth, one of the great men my friends and I admired and wanted to emulate. He remained one as I learned more about the world and about his work and his thought.
The New York Times reported today that he is accused (credibly) sexually abused women and girls as young as 13, and though morally every form of sexual abuse is an act of rape, that he committed rape by the legal definition as well. In addition to the women who spoke publicly, the Times added, “Mr. Chavez also used many of the women who worked and volunteered in his movement for his own sexual gratification.”
The revelation hit me as no other has. It knocked out a pillar of the way I see the world, which finds hope in the existence of truly great men and women who stand for the good of human beings against people and systems that do not want their good.
And Cesar Chavez was a hero.
The public and private man
“Through a series of grueling fasts, grape boycotts and marches that captured the world’s imagination, Mr. Chavez drew a spotlight to the plight of the American farmworker,” the Times reported. He “improved wages, living conditions and health care for generations of farmworkers and their families.”
He followed Martin Luther King Jr. in insisting on “militant nonviolence,” because he refused to hurt the people who hurt him and his people. In a violent world, turning the other cheek is a brave act, and a revolutionary one. It defeated southern racists and western agribusiness who seemed to have all the power.
He did that facing a powerful, organized opposition long settled into an oppressive system that made them lots of money and who were not afraid to use violence to keep it. He kept working when establishment institutions offered him advancement and the ability to do more good if only he were (as they saw it) more moderate and reasonable, when powerful people slandered him and kept up an unceasing opposition, when some of his friends and allies split with him.
Chavez was a great public man. But a very bad private man. And the private man is the best measure of a man.
As the old saying goes, character is what you do when no one is watching. I would add: and what you do when you have power over others and know you won’t get caught, because people invested in your public image will cover for you.
The private Chavez or the private any public figure, we don’t know. We can’t know them.
During the Me Too movement’s exposure of celebrity abusers, a friend shared a note that began: “This may make some of you mad, but I can’t stay silent about this topic. Please stop saying you’re mourning the loss of who you thought Matt Lauer was. Or Louie CK. Or whoever. You didn’t know them. You know who knew them? The women they tormented.”
An artificial world
Her last point is crucial, but so is the one before it. We know nothing about who these people really are.
We have no automatic reason to trust anyone in public life. We cannot assume in any particular case that the public man is the private man.
Public people — from celebrities to politicians to activists — live in an artificial world created by very clever people who work in a system highly evolved to create an image, in which image many people are invested, not least the public who want heroes and good stories.
And this gets to my friend’s last point. The abused women worked inside the system and saw the monster. But because so many people with power must keep up the monster’s image and so many people outside it buy the image the system’s created, because it pleases them to do so, people won’t listen.
Tragically, because Chavez was doing what he was doing in the public world, even some of his victims felt the need to be quiet. As his longtime colleague, and hero in her own right, Dolores Huerta wrote about her own abuse 60 years prior, “I carried this secret for as long as I did because building the movement and securing farmworker rights was my life’s work. The formation of a union was the only vehicle to accomplish and secure those rights and I wasn’t going to let Cesar or anyone else get in the way.”
The need for reasons
We need heroes. We need human reasons to hope. What do we do when our heroes are exposed and we know almost anyone we admire might not actually be the person we admire? It’s a horrible question to have to ask. We should be able to admire and emulate in confidence. Three things.
We can work on making ourselves better human beings, less likely to harm others. The season of Lent is for Christians a time to practice this. Even a purely secular person would benefit from a close encounter with the examination of conscience and from saying out loud, if only to the sky, what he’s done wrong and how sorry he is for doing it.
We can look at the world realistically. As Orwell wrote in his essay on Gandhi, “Saints should always be judged guilty until they are proved innocent.” For “saints,” read “public people.” Or in one of the wisest lines in the world’s literature, the psalmist’s “Put not your trust in princes.”
We can still admire and emulate great men and women, remembering we know only the public person and that we may be hurt to see the private person. I deeply wish Cesar Chavez had been in private what he was in public.
David Mills’ previous column was “America would be better if Trump were a Conservative.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.