It was a grim beginning to the panel. The moderator asked the bishop of Kharkiv, Ukraine, what life was like there. “We are always expecting, waiting for death,” he said through a translator. They try to help others as they can, but for everyone, “The point is to live, to survive the day.” Life there “makes the word ‘difficult’ meaningless.”

The priest with him told a story explaining why. A woman had shown him the video her soldier husband made in his last minutes. His company had been hit by a missile and he’d crawled away from the road. You could see the tourniquet on his leg, above the place it had been ripped off, the priest said. The man tells his wife he loves her, “and then you hear him praying. And then silence.”

The moderator started to say something, and the priest said, “I don’t want to talk any more. It’s too painful.”

Under relentless attack

Bishop Pavlo Honcharuk was speaking on Saturday at the New York Encounter, the annual meeting of a Catholic group called Communion and Liberation. He was joined by a priest of his diocese, Fr. Wojciech Stasiewicz, who runs the local branch of Caritas, the international Catholic charity. (The American branch is called Catholic Relief Services.)

Advertise with us

They are members of the Ukrainian Catholic Church, part of the Catholic church that shares the eastern worship and culture with the Orthodox. The church came to this region as Ukrainians immigrated to work in the mills and other industries. It now has eight parishes in the Pittsburgh area, including St. John the Baptist in South Side Flats.

The second largest city in Ukraine, Kharkiv sits in northeastern Ukraine next to the Russian-occupied Donbas region. It’s under relentless attack from Russian missiles and drones, aimed to kill and terrorize civilians, and directed attacks designed to destroy the city and region’s infrastructure. It’s under the threat of eventual Russian invasion.

It’s a modern city, and also an active war zone. The people of Kharkiv live knowing they might die in the next minute, or in their sleep, because of the number and unpredictability of the Russian attacks. They go about life mourning people who died, including soldiers, and soldiers whose fate is unknown.

Some live in homes without heat in the Ukrainian winter and everyone struggles in some way to get by. (For more stories from Ukraine, see the special reports from Ukraine by Susan Schulman in the Insight section.)

Having enjoyed the secure and peaceful life of an average American, I don’t know at what point the bad things that have happened to others turn into the bad things that could easily happen to you, so that the possibility shapes your daily life. The poor people of Kharkiv passed that point a long time ago.

Advertise with us

Living the tragedy

The moderator asked Bishop Honcharuk to describe a typical day. “Today was horrible! but today was very busy!” he replied, I think speaking of the day before he left for America, and laughed a little.

He had to fix a generator, he said, describing the process in detail. It must have taken hours. He was more of a mechanic than you would have thought. He then wrote letters and talked to a family whose son, a soldier, had disappeared. There was apparently a high likelihood they’d never find out what happened to him.

“By helping, by serving, you live this tragedy a different way,” he said. “If you stopped to think about it, you couldn’t stand it.” Some people lose their minds and “turn in on themselves,” he added.

The war had destroyed “three illusions,” he said, “belief in stability, security and peace amongst people.” For me, that was the starkest and saddest thing he said. To lose hope that the people around you will act decently makes the world much darker. Life becomes nasty, dull, brutish and short, as the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes put it.

You should, ideally, be able to expect even the enemy to obey the Law of War, to act decently, but the Russians don’t let morality get in the way of killing more Ukrainians. The army of an allegedly civilized nation cheerfully commits war crimes.

Advertise with us

I would like to say Bishop Honcharuk has been too affected by his experience, but I suspect our American great good fortune has blinded us to the normal run of things, the life most people experience. And to how blessed we have been. To have Canada and not Russia as a neighbor, for example.

Being with people

“I cannot leave,” the bishop said. “Because Christ is there with those who stay.” That was true of his people too, including those “who defend our fatherland.”

The moderator noted he was risking his life in staying. “I’ve already consented to that,” he said, meaning his death, and I was told he’s a Russian target. “It is important to consent to it, because then you concentrate on the people in front of us.”

Both Ukrainians said being there with people was the most important thing they did. “I can’t help,” said Fr. Stasiewicz, though he described helping a great deal, like finding people food and housing and running online schools. “Every word I say will be irrelevant. Two things remain: To listen and to cry together.”

“Each one of us is responsible for who we are in the world,” the bishop said. Believing in God means that “You feel loved. You feel your dignity. You know you are somebody. You know, because you can feel it. When you know who you are, you know what you must be.”

Advertise with us

Someone like Bishop Pavlo Honcharuk and Fr. Wojciech Stasiewicz, for example.

David Mills’s previous column was “Our dividing nation may not stand.”