My friend arrived at our local place about half an hour after the Texans-Steelers game ended. People had already run through the five stages of grief, I told her, and gotten to the final stage, acceptance. “I got to acceptance on week one,” she said.
Everyone who’d actually watched the game there began it feeling hopeful. But eventually we all saw the Steelers’ reality, and what I suspect most people secretly thought would happen happened.
A great parallel
Professional sports offer a great parallel for political life. By political I mean a political body’s attempt to get particular things done against opposition.
The pros feature extremely gifted people (and some who aren’t, usually in the owner’s box), very competitive and very driven, playing for a lot of money, who are held to brutally practical expectations by other people just as gifted, competitive and driven.
Everyone has huge incentives to do superlatively well. You win or you’re out, and if you’re out, you’re out of money, fame, attention, replaced by someone better than you, and this happens in front of the whole world.
They do what they do to a standard well above the politician’s, who often prefer political success over success for their cause. If pro teams fail, as they do (Texans 30, Steelers 6), political bodies will definitely fail. I think the Steelers’ season shows that, for at least six reasons.
People are deeply patriotic and almost nothing can change that. Not, for example, nine seasons without a playoff victory.
The people most disgusted with the Steelers’ play, who tell the bar at the end of the game that they’re done with the Steelers, come back the next week hoping for a win. Marriages break up more easily than fans do with their team.
Leaders can exploit that loyalty, either by doing what they shouldn’t or not bothering to do what they should. (This is, to be fair to the Steelers, more a lesson from the Pirates and their owner, Bob “It’s only about the Benjamins, not about the city” Nutting.)
You are not a player, on the field or in the owner’s box and the front office. You have no effect on what the team does. You may call the main number to complain, write angry letters, lead chants in the stands, rent planes to pull signs over the stadium on game day, you may feel loyalty and devotion exceeding that of the Rooneys, and nothing you do will change what happens on the field.
Disappointments and ignorance
[Foul substance] happens. Or doesn’t. We can’t count on anything working out. The best laid plans of mice and men etc.
Sometimes it happens and sometimes someone chooses it. T.J. Watt, one of the players the team absolutely depends upon, gets injured in a normal treatment that should have had him up and running right away. DK Metcalf, who is almost as important to the team, gets suspended for being somewhere he had no reason to be and smacking someone he’s not allowed to smack.
And sometimes foul substance happens to the other team. Like the Ravens kicker missing an easy game-winning field goal.
And sometimes it doesn’t matter. Like the great Chris Boswell missing a crucial extra point that could have given the game to the Ravens.
Those who think they know what’s going on disagree and the rest of us can’t be certain who’s right. I have listened to intense and learned arguments in our local place, between people who really understand football, who come to completely opposite conclusions. People online argue with unbelievable amounts of data and extraordinary subtlety, but no one ever convinces anyone else.
About Mike Tomlin especially, which leads to the next lesson.
People are unpredictably good and bad and hard to judge. His players reportedly love Tomlin, which is great. But does that mean he gets the most out of them or that he doesn’t push them enough? Did his care for his players bring wins that turned some losing seasons into winning seasons or bring playoff losses?
The things you have to know to accurately evaluate Tomlin’s coaching we can’t know. Maybe someone knows, but if knowing how good someone is was so easy, teams wouldn’t make so many bad draft choices.
The only way to win is to play. No other judgment matters.
The general lesson
I think the general political lesson to be learned from the Steelers’ season is a conservative one. We can’t form reality as we’d like, however good our intentions. Reality creates problems, frustrates our ambitions, makes the world worse than we think it needs to be.
It does that to the people in power, and we are (see the second lesson) several layers from power. We don’t know much, and little with certainty.
Political people on the right and left tend to forget this and believe they can do anything. They are not God. (If anything, rather on the other side.)
But that conservative lesson does not require conservative policies, even if it requires policies conservatively engaged. Reality does not provide an excuse for doing nothing. It makes doing something more difficult, it makes us think harder about how much can be done and in what way. It makes us work harder and accept continual failure.
But it does not absolve us from trying to make things better.
No matter how many games you win, you must never stop trying to win more. Get to acceptance on week one, but work for victory in the post-season. Accept that reality bites, and try to make it better.
David Mills’s previous column was “Why Donald Trump goes to war — and the Democrats would, too.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.