It’s easier to be thankful when you have something — or Someone — to thank, and believe that the world is on balance a better place than not, but it’s good to be grateful whether or not you have the metaphysical underpinnings for thanksgiving.
Because (I think) grateful people feel happier than ungrateful people and (I’m sure) make everyone else happier than ungrateful people do. The grateful see the world from a better angle or in a brighter light. They see the good things ungrateful people don’t see.
The ungrateful see the world as if it were a great big Costco warehouse with only a few items on the shelves and most of those items, things they don’t want. Grateful people see the world as a warehouse filled with things, most of which would be a great present to get.
But the value of giving thanks depends on what you’re giving thanks for. And there we have a problem.
The gift
But first, gratitude. It requires, as I said, seeing the world clearly, which means knowing how good you have it.
“Children are grateful when Santa Claus puts in their stockings gifts of toys or sweets,” the English writer G.K. Chesterton wrote. “Could I not be grateful to Santa Claus when he put in my stockings the gift of two miraculous legs? We thank people for birthday presents of cigars and slippers. Can I thank no one for the birthday present of birth?”
He made the same point in a poem titled “Evening”: “Here dies another day / During which I have had eyes, ears, hands / And the great world round me; / And with tomorrow begins another. / Why am I allowed two?”
Life is amazing. Why are we allowed, that is why are we given, so much of it? Think of all you see and hear and how much you can do with your hands.
Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel said the same thing in a more religious way. “How strange we are in the world, and how presumptuous our doings!” he said. “Only one response can maintain us: gratefulness for witnessing the wonder, for the gift of our unearned right to serve, to adore, and to fulfill. It is gratefulness which makes the soul great.”
And on the other hand, as a supposed Yiddish proverb put it, “If you cannot be grateful for what you have received, then be thankful for what you have been spared.” That things could be worse is by itself a positive blessing for which to be thankful, in a world in which life can get abundantly worse.
Real gratitude does not mean ignoring the world’s pain or acting as if life did not mix pain and suffering in with the good things. It’s not an expression of mere optimism. Someone I love is slowly dying of cancer and that is a continuous pain and a reminder that in some ways the world just sucks.
But it also provides reason for thanks. The developments of modern medicine even in the years she’s been sick have kept her alive. The extra years we have. The care of doctors who pulled all-nighters to learn to do what they do. The care and concern of friends. The lessons being sick or loving a sick person teaches you and whatever ways the experience makes you a slightly better person.
The problem
Most of us have much to be thankful for. In general, I think we should say thank you — to God, the universe, existence, as you believe — for specific gifts, like fingers or friends, bringing them to mind. It’s too easy to feel grateful without being actually grateful.
But there is a problem. Perhaps our nation’s most popular single thanksgiving these days is “I think you, God, that I’m not like that guy.”
Social media has become a mechanism for looking down on others and marking yourself as one of the good guys, and making sure your gang knows it. Your posts get likes, and your columns get readers, the more harshly you write about people who think differently from you.
You’d just be a bigot for denouncing people for their race, origin, class, sex, gender, neighborhood, ancestry, etc. But you can attain instant righteousness for denouncing them for their views. You enlist in the army of the great and good and the more people you denounce and the more strongly you denounce them, the higher in rank you rise.
We have, alas, an example at the very top. The president can’t post anything without denouncing his enemies, in the most intemperate and often ridiculous terms. He may never have written an item that expressed genuine, simple gratitude, for someone or something that was good in itself, not just good for him.
Ah, but. A humane life requires recognizing that you are in some way like that guy. That you are probably, in part, Donald Trump. Whatever is wrong with him is probably wrong with you too, at least to a small degree.
An answer
In this time of harsh division, I think we should say thank you for people with whom we have deep disagreements, bringing them to mind as we do. It’s a way of treating the Trump in us. I admit I can’t feel grateful for Trump et al. I’ve tried, and I can’t think of a reason to.
But I can thank God for Trumpian people I know, even though I reject their politics. They are not their politics, but people with gifts and virtues, and faults no greater than my own. They are gifts to be thankful for.
David Mills’ previous column was “The humane way to talk about economics.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.