It is better to stand alone, but with a clean conscience, than to stand with all the rest, but with a giant stain on our conscience.” Pier Giorgio Frassati had been disappointed to find that his political party, which had begun just three years before with such high ideals and such high hopes, had decided to ally itself with the rising political movement of the day.
Politically understandable, as a pragmatic move to gain influence in the new government for their causes. But that rising movement was, unfortunately, the Fascist party led by Benito Mussolini, which was quickly and quite consciously destroying the country’s democratic institutions.
A new saint
Frassati, who died of polio in 1925 at the age of 24, was declared a saint by Pope Leo last Sunday. The son of a prominent family — his father founded the liberal newspaper La Stampa and served in the Italian senate — he was obviously devout, hence being declared a saint, and two main expressions of his devotion were an intense and courageous engagement in the politics of the day and an energetic and sacrificial service of the poor. He was an extraordinary young man.
He is said to have often given away his tram fare and walked home, and when asked why he travelled in the train’s third class carriage said because there was no fourth class. His sister Luciana writes in “Man of the Beatitudes” that upon arriving in Berlin as a teenager when it was 12 below zero, he gave a freezing homeless man his overcoat. When he was older, he spent part of almost every day gathering food and clothes and wheeling them in a cart to the poor neighborhoods.
He openly opposed the Fascists, joining and even leading protests and marches, which were always threatened with Fascist violence. When a group of Fascists came to smash up the Frassati’s home, he fought them off and chased them down the street. He was arrested several times and did not use his privileged position to leave jail until his comrades did. He was a marked man.
Whatever one’s beliefs, one can find some saints inspirations and models, their religion aside. St. Pier Giorgio Frassati is one for people involved in public life who want to live by principle — for truth, justice, goodness, brotherhood, kindness, in other words, for virtue — and not for power. (A smaller number than we would like to think. People who want power tend not to say no to those who have it.)
He doesn’t offer an example of political success. The rising political movement he fought rose so fast and so high for a reason. It gave a lot of people what they wanted.
It offered them clear, simple answers to their country’s problems and dispensed with the frustrating restraints and mutual tolerance of democratic life. It gave them brothers in battle and enemies to hate. It promised to return Italy to the glory and power of its past. It incarnated itself in one great leader.
And whatever power it gained, it used to gain more. Any movement that could have politically defeated the Fascists could only have done so by becoming fascists themselves.
Frassati could no more stop the Fascist movement with his words and witness than he could have stopped a tidal wave by holding up his hand on the beach and crying “Stop!”
The political lessons
The first political lessons of Frassati’s life, I think, is that you never stop fighting for the good and never accept the bad, because the bad doesn’t become the good just because it wins, and what good is your life if you don’t fight for the good?, and how can you live with yourself if you accept the bad? The second is that you do as much good for the vulnerable and marginalized as you can.
The second both encourages the first and counters the discouragement you will feel from the first. Caring for people you know makes possible caring for people as a group well and with insight.
The first requires seeing what’s there and what it requires, and not convincing yourself that a bad movement can be used for your own purposes. “Right thinking people,” Luciana wrote, with irony, “convinced themselves, or at least were convinced that fascism was a cheap and useful broom to sweep the communists out of Italy. Naturally once they had been driven out, again according to these smug people, the broom would be thrown in a corner.”
Frassati saw Fascism clearly. He asked what ideals“the great scandal” had. “Filthy lucre, paid by industrialists and, shamefully, also by our government. They act induced only by money and dishonesty.” He saw, Lucianaa wrote “that Christianity, a religion of love, absolutely could not agree with Fascism, a doctrine that exalted force and violence.”
Near the end of his short life, he wrote a friend: “I remember the first elections after the war, the coming of fascism and now I recall with joy that we were never for fascism for a single moment of our lives. We always fought against this scourge of Italy.” Pier Giorgio Frassati didn’t win, but he fought the good fight.
David Mills’ previous column was “The dive-bar Manfred Honeck loves her work.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.