He’s a “real ‘sleazebag’” and a “bad person who, in his own way, probably hates America, and obviously has his own separate ambitions.” Donald Trump’s judgment must have surprised the target.
Trump seems to have been enraged, as he so often is, at being told no.
The man who shaped America
In the president’s first term, his target, Leonard Leo, was apparently the one person in American whose suggestions he took without much objection. This hitherto obscure lawyer, a behind the scenes player in the conservative legal world as a leader of the Federalist Society, is arguably the man who, after Trump, has most shaped America for the next ten or twenty years.
Leo recommended people to nominate to the top level of judges, the people who would not only decide what the law means in particular cases but what it means, period. Trump appointed about 25% of those jurists and some, having lifetime appointments, will be in office for decades.
Among them are the three Supreme Court nominations — Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — who gave the Court a conservative super-majority. For doing that, for listening to Leo, Trump received almost universal praise from his supporters.
And now Leonard Leo’s a sleazebag etc.
Because one set of judges on one court made Trump mad by ruling against his beloved but legally dubious tariffs. Judges who were not, and this is Trump to the core, on a court for which Leo had recommended names.
Leo, who knows how to play the game, simply thanked Trump for “transforming the Federal Courts” and declared “the Federal Judiciary is better than it’s ever been in modern history.” He’d gotten what he wanted. He could take being insulted.
They are both transactional
I asked two law professors I know for their thoughts about the Leo affair. They both teach at Duquesne’s Thomas R. Kline School of Law.
John Rago was concerned about the relation of the Federalist Society, whose work he praised, and Trump. Though the Society says it takes no partisan positions, Leo’s relation with Trump “suggests that this is no longer the case. If true, this is much more than regrettable.”
Bruce Ledewitz, who besides teaching law writes for us every two weeks, describes both Trump and Leo as “transactional.”
The president assumes “there is a way to do whatever he thinks best for the country and also assumes that if he appointed a judge, that judge will help him attain those goals.”
Trump (this is me, not Ledewitz, though I think he’d agree) doesn’t understand, or doesn’t want to understand, how the American legal system works. The hero of people who say they love the Constitution doesn’t give a rat’s behind for the Constitution. It just annoys him.
He sees judges and justices as employees. They’re not to read the words of the Constitution and say as best they can what it means today. They’re to rule that it endorses the president’s policies.
So why have the higher courts? Why did America’s founders put a third branch of government, a separate but equal branch, into the Constitution? That only that makes sense if the founders saw — with “an abundance of wisdom and deep thought,” Rago noted — the need for an independent body that would protect the political system they created.
Trump doesn’t care. “His frustration is perfectly understandable when judges follow the law rather than his wishes,” Ledewitz said.
As for Leo, he said, “his recent response to Trump — the judiciary is better than ever — shows that he is also transactional, rather than legally oriented. Leo got what he wanted — a more conservative judiciary.”
He’s not sure how conservative the Supreme Court really is, though. A conservative court would be “originalist,” deciding cases as the founding fathers would have decided them. It has not done so in the cases about the Colorado ballot and presidential immunity, he says, in both of which it ruled for Trump.
Both Ledewitz and Rago were most worried about what the whole affair teaches people about the judicial system. “Fundamentally, everybody agrees with Trump that judges just vote their politics,” said Ledwitz. “This is the victory of legal realism and nihilism.”
“Of course judicial appointments are part of a political process,” Rago said, noting that the ABA’s recommendations had leaned liberal. “That’s fine. But if Leo’s efforts to introduce hard-lined ideological views are accurately reported, only peril can follow.”
To be fair, he continued, “whether these ideologies arise from hard right or hard left doesn’t matter. Both are wrong and both create a tenuous condition in the public’s confidence in our Judiciary.”
Helping a dictator
Ledewitz noted that Leo had done more than recommend conservative judges. “Leo does not seem the least bit concerned that he has helped put a would-be dictator in the White House. The framers would point out to him that the Constitution is a whole and the courts are not enough to sustain the Constitution.” A president who respects the courts and the law is also required.
From what I know of Leo from people who know him, I think he’s a true believer, who was willing to make a deal with anyone to put other true believers on the courts. He was happy to give Donald Trump legitimacy then, and happy to continue doing so now.
There’s a cost to that. As a friend said to me, if you lie down with dogs, you’ll wake up with fleas. You can do that if you want, but if you do you shouldn’t by your words and actions deny the fleas and recommend others lie down with the dog.
David Mills’ previous column was “Why modern politics is civil war carried on by other means.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.