There is no good cause that can’t be used to advance a bad one. In Congress, as I write, three college presidents are testifying before the House’s Committee on Education and Workforce on what they’ve done to suppress anti-Semitism and protect their Jewish students and faculty.

This would be more believable if not driven by a president not hitherto noted for his opposition to antisemitism, nor in challenging people in his own party who flirt with it. After — after — the rapper Kanye West/Ye praised Hitler and declared he was going “Death Con 3 on Jewish people,” Donald Trump had him and a white supremacist leader (whom we can safely assume was also an antisemite) to dinner in his home, and then called West “a really nice guy” with a “good heart.”

A real bind for Jews

Maybe possibly he cares about anti-Semitism. But if so, I don’t believe that’s the reason he and his movement have taken up the cause.

Accusing them of coddling and thereby encouraging anti-Semitism offers a great way to beat down the major universities and colleges, a huge institutional complex with the money and power to resist the president. He does not like people who can say no to him, and he enjoys defeating and subduing them. He loves wedge issues he can use to divide the opposition.

Advertise with us

Sincere or not, the hearings and threats do bring attention to anti-Semitism and (I hope but doubt) make it even less acceptable than it was. But politicizing it also trivializes a genuine evil and only encourages the antisemites to resent and hate Jews more.

It endangers a small and vulnerable minority, who ought, by the rules of American liberalism, to be carefully protected from hatefulness. “American Jews number not much more than 5 million, a mere 2.2% of the population,” Rabbi Seth Adelson pointed out.

An ADL survey conducted last year found that 24% of Americans agreed with at least 6 of 11 anti-Jewish statements. It’s a rough measure of antisemitism, but then no one should agree with one, much less six. That 24% means over 50 million Americans. 50 freaking million. And the younger they are, the higher number of statements the average person agrees with.

“Many Jews feel like we are in a real bind right now,” Rabbi Adelson told me. The rabbi of Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill explained that “On the one hand, anti-Semitic incidents have skyrocketed since the Hamas attack of Oct. 7, 2023. We feel like the Jewish people were attacked, and then have continued to be attacked for the last year and a half. And so the fact that politicians have taken an interest in containing antisemitic activity on college campuses is generally supported by Jews.”

On the other hand, “we are also aware that anti-Semitism is a phenomenon which extends across the political aisle, and the fact that the world’s oldest form of hatred is being used as a political football is deeply concerning.”

Advertise with us

Encouraged hate groups

Trump and his allies aren’t wrong about the academic world. Many universities failed to protect the Jewish members of their communities, letting pro-Hamas protesters violate campus rules and disrupt campus life.

At places like Columbia and UCLA, the protesters kept “Zionist” and “colonizing” Jewish students out of some parts of campus and verbally and apparently physically threatened many, especially those who challenged them. Many groups of protesters were hate groups, or at least hateful groups. At Pitt, the second of the handwritten “camp rules” for last year’s protest encampment said “Don’t talk to Zionists!” with an arrow pointing to the instruction “[Expletive] pigs!”

The universities’ administrations apparently did not realize the rage the protesters felt and their implacable sense of their own righteousness — and the dislike of “the Jews” that many radicals seem to feel, on the left as much as the right, but rarely have an excuse to let out. How many actually cared about the Palestinians is a question. (I speak, by the way, from youthful experience, except for the anti-Semitism.)

The administrations also didn’t see how blithely the protesters would reject the basic rules of liberal democratic society, upon which the life of the university rests. Rules that evolved, partly through Jewish influence, to let people live together even when divided by an issue as polarizing as Israel’s response to Hamas, they blew off as repressive.

Trump’s dangerous game

And that brings us back to the dangerous game Donald Trump is playing. “The use of anti-Semitism as a political cudgel strikes me as a serious threat to Jews and Jewish life in America,” Rabbi Daniel Fellman of Temple Sinai in Squirrel Hill told me.

Advertise with us

It has “exploded into a major problem,” he said, and one major cause was “its embrace by the right, who in the name of supporting a particular candidate for president have been willing to accept support from those once thought beyond the pale. One side empowers the hate, allows it to fester openly, and now tries to swoop in and solve the problem without owning the fact that they themselves have created the problem!”

Jews and all Americans “do best when we move toward the center and listen to each other with respect. A move to the extremes hurts all of us. Right now we Jews are feeling the pain of both extremes. Soon, I fear, more and more Americans will share in that pain. The sooner we can move back toward the middle, the better.”

David Mills’ previous column was “Donald Trump and ICE's careless brutality.”