The big foreign affairs subject on everyone’s mind in the wake of the Iranians’ U.S. drone shootdown and President Donald J. Trump’s on-again, off-again military response to it has to be this: Where does this leave us in terms of the Middle East and, also, with the 2020 presidential campaign heating up, with two rounds of Democratic debates coming this week?
Except for the potentially violent ensuite of the shootdown, I am glad to learn that a surface-to-air missile can bring down a drone, even though they cost millions. There is a fundamental problem with impersonal warfare. One earlier practitioner of the profession, Gen. Robert E. Lee, observed correctly, “It is well that war is so terrible — we would grow too fond of it.” My instinct on seeing a drone overhead is to want to bring it down.
Mr. Trump’s vacillation on an aerial attack on Iran provokes confusion all around, on the part of Americans, Iranians, America’s remaining allies, our ostensible enemies and observers on the fence. The first question is, assuming that Mr. Trump listens at all to other people, who favored what U.S. response to Iran’s action? I assume that National Security Advisor John Bolton, a warmonger, and Secretary of State and former Kansas congressman, the relatively unreflective Mike Pompeo, favored hitting the Iranians with the kitchen sink. There is no secretary of defense with Gen. Jim Mattis having resigned on a matter of principle and his intended successor having crashed and burned on a moral issue. Thus, it had to be America’s military, led by the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Joseph Dunford, who likely talked Mr. Trump down, based on the military realities of a war with Iran at this time, or any time.
Such a war would find the United States sprawled across the Middle East, vulnerable — in effect, with its pants down. We have bases and troops in Oman, Qatar, Kuwait, Iraq, Bahrain and Abu Dhabi, all within easy reach of Iran. Then there is Israel. Iran has no reason to hold back. We have already sworn to destroy its economy and have pulled out of the international accord to swap limits on Iran’s nuclear program in return for the removal of economic sanctions against it, leaving China, France, the European Union, Germany, Russia and the United Kingdom — the other signatories — twisting in the breeze.
Mr.Trump undoubtedly, in considering to attack or not, factored in the imminent 2020 election campaign. He would probably like to avoid the sort of slogans that governed other wartime political campaigns, such as “LBJ, LBJ, how many kids have you killed today?” Or this anti-conservative chant for Barry Goldwater: “In your heart, you know he’s right; in your guts, you know he’s nuts.”
A winning war president might do well. One who has taken us into an unnecessary war where we are getting pounded and our troops are dying will do much less well at the ballot box. What the petulant Mr. Trump wants right now is a second term.
Read More
America’s remaining allies — European, Asian and North American — must have found the whole thing nerve-rattling. They know that if America starts a war, or gets pulled into one by undisciplined Iranians with fingers on triggers, it will be no time until we will be asking them to contribute troops or other resources to the thankless project. In that sense, they must have been glad that Mr. Trump called off the attack.
In another sense, the erratic attack order, reflecting what has to be called a chaotic chain of command in Washington, had to reinforce the already strong impression that the White House is run by a clown and sycophantic nothings for the most part, having somehow scrambled to a reasonable conclusion on the attack on Iran for the time being.
The Sunni states of the Persian Gulf, led by Saudi Arabia and the murderous Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, must be very disappointed that we didn’t attack Iran, their Shiite enemy. So must beleaguered Israeli candidate and current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Jared Kushner probably didn’t want a U.S. attack on Iran to rain on his attempted Bahrain conference parade.
It is possible that the current Iran drama will push up viewership to this week’s Democratic debates. or produce more serious discussion of foreign affairs issues. But I doubt it, even though Mr. Trump came close to committing an enormous amount of American lives and resources to another pointless war. Do any of us really care what regime rules in Tehran?
All in all, the drone-down affair could be considered a relatively cost-free test of this White House’s — this president’s — ability to respond to a dangerous situation. Voters will have a chance to judge, and express their assessment at the polls.
Dan Simpson, a former U.S. ambassador, is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (dhsimpson999@gmail.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.