U.S. policy in the Middle East is thoroughly gummed up with both Iran and America threatening war, though neither country needs or wants one. This dangerous and undesirable state of affairs is due largely to mistakes on our side, brought about for unclear or suspect reasons, perhaps personal rather than based in sober evaluation of the best interests of the country.

The first mistake was to unilaterally withdraw the United States from the agreement that included China, France, Germany, Russia and the United Kingdom for Iran to limit its nuclear program in return for a reduction of economic sanctions against it. One objective of this accord was to remove Iran from the list of nuclear-armed nations capable of destroying mankind’s ability to live on at least part of the planet. A second objective was to begin a process of drawing the ayatollah-led Tehran regime back into the family of at least semi-civilized nations willing to abide by international agreements. The United States, under President Donald Trump, tossed both of these objectives out the window, probably mostly because the agreement had been achieved under the leadership of his predecessor, Barack Obama.

Thus, rather than the United States and the rest of the world now looking at an Iran with its people living better and its government playing ball with the rest of us, more subject to global norms, instead we wonder whether Iran and its clients are preparing for war against us and our interests not only in the Middle East but in other vulnerable areas as well.

The second mistake we have made, related to the first one, is to have involved ourselves in the Saudi Arabian-led Sunni Muslim conflict against the Iranian-led Shiite Muslim nations in the Middle East. There is no fundamental reason for us to sign on with either side. The Iran nuclear-sanctions accord could have served as a basis for us to stand between the two, with credibility on both sides. Instead, by signing on to the Sunni side, we are identified through our military support with the Saudis and United Arab Emirates.

Advertise with us

That means we also are associated, through Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, with the brutal murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi and the murderous bombing campaign that the Saudis and Emiratis have waged in Yemen, killing thousands and condemning many more to life without medical care, education and housing. Saudi intervention in what remains basically a civil war between Yemeni Sunnis and Houthi Shiite rebels, supported lightly by Iran, has make Yemen virtually uninhabitable. American arms and logistical support fuel the Sunni war effort.

Our role in the Sunni war effort in Yemen supports war crimes. Our intervention in the Sunni vs. Shiite religious war in the Middle East has no moral or strategic basis in logic. U.S. companies’ arms sales to the Sunnis weigh in the overall U.S. posture, although U.S. sales to Iran, given free sway, would undoubtedly become important again, as they were pre-ayatollah.

Instead, we are looking at what last week was being experimentally floated: the possibility of sending 100,000 more U.S. troops to the Middle East in response to shadowy threats against U.S. bases in Kuwait, Bahrain, the United Arab Emirates and Oman, and the possibility of another war added to those in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya and Somalia.

Why? One shrinks from a conclusion that American economic prosperity depends upon lots of foreign arms sales. One also shrinks from the conclusion that we are being sucked into war against Iran because it is Israel’s most worrisome enemy at the moment. It is particularly troubling that Mr. Trump’s current national security adviser, John Bolton, has wanted a war with Iran for many years. It also is disturbing to think that Mr. Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, has business interests that enter into America’s security posture in the flashpoint Middle East.

Worst of all is the thought that Mr. Trump wants a war prior to the 2020 elections to make himself a war president as George W. Bush did with the Iraq invasion in 2003 before the 2004 elections.

Advertise with us

We have no taste for another war, costing American lives and tax dollars, in Iran, North Korea or Venezuela. Let’s see instead a truce between the White House and Congress that makes possible the passage of an infrastructure bill before our bridges fall down.

Dan Simpson, a former U.S. ambassador, is a columnist for the Post-Gazette (dhsimpson999@gmail.com).