Time was, when you read a history book, you could find yourself thinking, “Sounds awful. I wonder what that must have been like.”
There’s little need for that anymore. We’re not halfway through 2020 and we seem to have covered almost everything.
Deadly pandemic? Check. Depression-level unemployment? Check. Urban riots? Check.
No longer do you need to have lived in 1918, the 1930s or 1968 to have experienced those ordeals. We’ve squeezed all of that into just a few months.
If what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, America is plenty strong by now. Maybe the fates should let up a little.
One bad idea we have dodged is the militarization of our streets. Longtime Pittsburghers, here for the G-20 conference in the fall of 2009, should remember what that was like. I can’t be the only one concerned by that particular trial balloon that President Donald Trump sent up June 1.
Read More
If governors did not deploy the National Guard “in sufficient numbers that we dominate the streets,” Mr. Trump said, he’d send in the United States military “and quickly solve the problem for them.”
That notion went blessedly nowhere, not least because former military and White House brass, most notably James Mattis, let the commander-in-chief know that would be a bad move. Mr. Mattis, the retired Marine general who resigned as secretary of defense in 2018, wrote that troops sworn to uphold the Constitution should not be “ordered under any circumstance to violate the constitutional rights of their fellow citizens. ... We must reject any thinking of our cities as a ‘battlespace’” or set up “a conflict — a false conflict — between the military and civilian society.”
His warning took me back almost 11 years to the days when the city created a kind of martial-law theme park on the shutdown streets of the Golden Triangle and beyond.
Not many got to experience this. That’s because before the conference even began, the city adopted this motto: “We’re not going to let any anarchists shut down Pittsburgh; we’ll do it.”
It wasn’t hard. Not many cities come with two-thirds of a moat, but once you shut down the bridges across the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers, there you don’t go. Yet Maj. Gen. Robert Scales, former commandant of the U.S. Army War College in Carlisle, told me even before the G-20 began that the terrain was less important than the psychology of mobs: “As a general rule, the unpleasantness is started by a small percentage.’’
That can be true on both sides of the barricades.
More than 4,000 cops and more than 2,000 National Guardsmen came into Pittsburgh that September. In a very short time, it was clear nothing was clear. Nobody, in or out of uniform, seemed entirely sure where people could walk or couldn’t. In fairness, Pittsburghers had until then lived in a city where only crime was against the law.
A cop yelled at me one afternoon for walking on a sidewalk that had become the wrong sidewalk. At least he was pretty sure it was the wrong sidewalk and preferred to err on the side of pedestrian prohibition. And around 4 p.m. one Thursday near the intersection of Seventh and Liberty, riot police in something like “Star Wars” armor stood 15 feet across and several rows deep, billy clubs at the ready, when one lone protester stepped before the imposing force carrying only a sign, which read:
“Pirates Rebuilding Since 1993.”
That was funny. That same afternoon and night, people in Lawrenceville and Oakland weren’t laughing. Police turned pepper spray on crowds that wouldn’t disperse, and some in those crowds smashed windows and rolled dumpsters down the street. Even where there was no violence, police rolled out a long-range acoustic device to disperse crowds, emitting sounds so obnoxious they might make a freight train take a dirt road.
Before the conference ended, it was clear it could have been policed with a considerably smaller force, less expense and more businesses open. Hours after the conferees flew off for home, police arrested vanloads of people in Oakland for being outside on a nice night. Later, the city quietly paid close to a million dollars in settlements to people who sued for being unjustly arrested.
The riot in Pittsburgh on Saturday, May 30, properly called the hijacking of a peaceful march, was far more serious. Our attention was diverted from the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis by hundreds of thousands of dollars in damages from vandalism and looting, two burning police vehicles, police and journalists injured, and 45 arrests. There have been a number of peaceful protests since, though a clash between police and protesters in East Liberty on Monday, June 1, is under investigation by the Office of Municipal Investigations and the Citizen Police Review Board. We’ll be hearing a lot about who did what to whom.
What we won’t be seeing, thankfully, are armed soldiers barricading our streets. Our police officers have an extraordinarily difficult job, and the degree of difficulty has risen. Not all the old ways of policing will survive, nor should they. But we all should reject safe, smug cynicism when there are signs of progress.
Last Friday, Pittsburgh police Chief Scott Schubert knelt with protesters during a demonstration in his boyhood neighborhood, Beechview, saying later:
“I did it for all minorities who have experienced decades — centuries, actually — of systemic racism and discrimination. I did it for all of those people around me on Friday, peaceful protesters who want real and meaningful change, not ill-conceived, knee-jerk reactions. ... I also did it for our officers. The Pittsburgh Bureau of Police has focused for years on building bridges with all of our communities, and I want the public to see that, too.”
That sure beat the blast of another long-range acoustic device. That’s the America we should all want to live in, and a 2020 vision long overdue.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.