The only sport I care much about is baseball, which means I don’t tune into sports radio in the wintertime. I don’t care who’s skating on the Penguins’ third line, who Pitt will hire to coach hoops or whether the Steelers will draft another long snapper.
But I sometimes envy the passion I hear from callers when my radio grazes across sports talk. Would that we all had such outlets. Sure, there’s talk radio that touches on all topics, but wouldn’t it be great if there were some hyper-specialized show for, say, classical music?
“Hey, Biff, first time caller. Do ya think the Pittsburgh Symphony has any shot at drafting this cellist Wang down at Julliard?”
Or what about “The Pittsburgh Infrastructure Show”? Sure, 90 percent of the calls would be about potholes, bike lanes or snow removal, but it could also be where people get into the nitty-gritty of Pittsburgh’s pitch to get Amazon’s second headquarters here.
We don’t know what the city and Allegheny County are offering (which is outrageous), but we do know a successful bid could change Pittsburgh forever. Like most change, it would be neither all good nor all bad, but meantime it would be nice to at least hear educated guesses on the odds of landing Amazon HQ2.
That’s why a long email from Samuel Koda, a 1990 Pitt graduate with a degree in economics who has worked for IBM and The Hershey Co., intrigued me so.
Read More
Mr. Koda, 49, likes Pittsburgh’s chances in what is said to be a 20-city competition, but he hasn’t found a good outlet for his analysis. His take, which I’ve shamelessly shortened to adapt to our soundbite era, goes something like this:
“Mainstream media’s analysis has been disappointing.” Some early “favorites” such as Minneapolis and Detroit didn’t survive the first cut, and there’s no way the Washington, D.C., area is going get Amazon HQ2. Sure, three finalists are in and around the nation’s capital, but Amazon desperately needs a counternarrative to the perception that the company is too powerful a force in the American economy.
Apart from the greater expense of locating in or near D.C., “a retailer relies on the trust of its customers as much as — if not more than — other businesses.” This public selection process is largely about giving Amazon executives a feel-good marketing story, and landing among the pols wouldn’t provide that.
“They don’t want to be seen as the job killer. They want to be seen as the job creator. If they go to D.C. or New York, that won’t be the story.”
Atlanta? It has a busy airport and tech jobs, but it’s also “a car-centric commuting nightmare, an L.A. East that one would think Amazon wants to avoid at all costs.”
Toronto? It might have an easier task attracting foreign talent than an American city in the Trump era, and it has a “Seattle vibe,” but locating in Canada would mean an international trip anytime an employee goes to another Amazon location. Next.
Dallas and Austin? As with Atlanta, Mr. Koda believes hostility to LGBTQ issues within the state dim Texan chances. The climate change that has turned the Sun Belt into the Drought Belt is likely a concern, too.
Pittsburgh? It has the cheapest housing and proximity to the Northeast. Amazon would rather not pay Boston or New York wages to its software engineers. “If Amazon is to beat the the Googles and Walmarts and Nordstroms in online retail, it will need to keep its costs down.” The company’s recent initiatives in health care, pharmaceuticals, banking and logistics also play to Pittsburgh’s strengths, he said.
The HQ2 branding by Amazon might be a misnomer, he said, as this new location may be more back office than second headquarters. He and I both believe it possible that Amazon won’t put all its eggs in one basket; it could pick a winner but also drop thousands of jobs among a handful of other cities. Given the choice, Mr. Koda would rather see Pittsburgh get 5,000 jobs than 50,000 — “it wouldn’t be that massive disruption” — but he doesn’t want to see the city miss out altogether.
Mr. Koda earned a law degree from Brooklyn Law School in 1997, and he’s watched as Brooklyn has gone from a beaten-down borough to a global brand (and among the most expensive places to live on Earth). From his home in Hershey, he’s watched the Pittsburgh brand growing in stature, too.
His would have been a great call for “The Pittsburgh Infrastructure Show,” but it lacks a dial tone.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.