No matter how you slice it — and Dr. Neal Schorr has sliced this as many ways as a deli ham — Pittsburgh never has gotten its fair share of state money for urban highway reconstruction these past 50 years.
Dr. Schorr, 62, knows Philadelphia has more people and should get more money. But taking every variable into account — population, average daily traffic, miles of roads — he figures Philadelphia and Harrisburg receive between 4 to 24 times as much funding as Pittsburgh.
“This is a political problem,” says the retired Marshall physician who has been a lifelong student and critic of Pennsylvania highways.
He can present a funding chart for every doubt anyone might have. So as President Donald Trump offers America a $1.5 trillion infrastructure plan without much money in it — all but $200 billion would need to come from state, local and private sources — let’s take a look at one studious man’s take on why Western Pennsylvania highways aren’t better.
Start with population. Throw out those parts of Greater Philadelphia in neighboring states and its metro area is about one and three-quarters the size of Pittsburgh’s. The Harrisburg metro area is one-quarter the size of Pittsburgh’s.
After adjusting for population, Dr. Schorr figures the Philadelphia region got almost eight times as much money to reconstruct an urban slice of Interstate 95 as Pittsburgh received for the Parkway West from the Fort Pitt Tunnel to I-79. Harrisburg got almost 22 times as much to reconstruct I-83.
Naysayers might say hold up, Doc, you aren’t adjusting for all the long-distance commuters on I-95. But the fact is, those making long hauls mostly bypass Philadelphia on the New Jersey Turnpike; the portion of I-95 in the City of Brotherly Love is largely daily commuters.
When Dr. Schorr compared average daily traffic for the busiest urban expressways in Pittsburgh, Harrisburg and Philadelphia, they were actually pretty close.
Some 140,000 vehicles cross the Fort Pitt Bridge daily and, after some drop-off on Carson Street, 100,000 are on the Parkway West, according to 2012 PennDOT figures.
Harrisburg, meantime, has 114,000 to 130,000 on two key slices of Interstate 83, and the Cottman-Girard Avenue segment of I-95 in Philadelphia hits 190,000.
That doesn’t seem like a lot of difference, does it?
Yet when Dr. Schorr looked at dollars spent per lane mile on I-83 in Harrisburg vs I-376 in Pittsburgh, and adjusts for population, he finds $16.75 million was spent per lane mile in Harrisburg — and $29.65 per lane mile per capita. On I-376 in Pittsburgh, those same figures are $3.2 million per lane mile and $1.35 per capita.
As for Philadelphia, had Pittsburgh received for the Parkway West the same amount of funding per capita as Philadelphia did to reconstruct the Girard Avenue segment of I-95, we’d have been given $570 million instead of $73 million.
A $1 billion investment in the Harrisburg region’s transportation system began in 2014, and Pittsburgh can’t even get basic structural improvements like acceleration lanes at the Parkway West’s Greentree Road interchange.
A Latin phrase in law, res ipsa loquitur, means “the thing speaks for itself.’’ A litigant might use the phrase when a surgeon leaves a scalpel inside the patient after sewing him up. That term applies here, too, Dr. Schorr believes.
“If you’ve got the money in Philadelphia and Harrisburg, then you’ve got the money here. We pay the same gas tax and registration fees.’’
But who will speak for Pittsburgh? Dr. Schorr has no complaints with District 11 of PennDOT, which he sees doing great work with the money it’s allotted. Our problem is how the state divvies up the spoils, though, of course, PennDOT doesn’t buy Dr. Schorr’s argument.
“Cherry-picking numbers from a few projects to buttress an argument that the Pittsburgh region is shortchanged does not account for the challenges I have outlined here,’’ PennDOT spokesman Rich Kirkpatrick said at the end of a long email sent late Wednesday. PennDOT must “stretch limited resources as far as we can to keep the entire system in as good a shape as possible.”
Dr. Schorr lives in House Speaker Mike Turzai’s district. He’s been trying without success since last March to get a meeting with him (Dr. Schorr shared his email exchange with Mr. Turzai’s office, and says he’s stopped by the district office seven times.) They’re scheduled to finally meet with a PennDOT district highway engineer in late March.
I’ve not made a pothole-sized dent in the analysis Dr. Schorr has done here, but then he’s been at this kind of thing for some time. He may be the only medical student who ever landed two summer internships at PennDOT; he drove every mile of Interstate in the commonwealth before he turned 25; and, 15 years ago, PennDOT endorsed his detailed proposal to add a tunnel on both sides of the Fort Pitt Tunnel to ease congestion inbound and outbound — but the state never funded it.
When I mentioned that that traffic always grows to fill widened highways, and it’s impossible to pave your way out of congestion, he was ready for that, too.
“Give us $2 billion to extend the light rail out [to Pittsburgh International Airport],” he said. “I already have the route figured out.”
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.