America’s Largest Full-Time State Legislature is famously tardy. We’re now a solid two months past the deadline for a balanced state budget and Pennsylvania is also the last big gas-producing state without a severance tax.
That’s just a coincidence. Even if we had a reasonable tax, it couldn’t balance the budget all by itself. But we should do it anyway because the rest of us are about to be asked to make serious sacrifices, and the drilling industry needs to do its share, too.
Anyone who doubts that this is the right course should read a recent blog post by a senior research associate for Resources for the Future. That’s a nonprofit think tank that’s been around 65 years and doesn’t advocate for any governmental policy or candidate. But after Daniel Raimi of RFI looked at the severance tax approved in July by the Pennsylvania Senate (and as yet unapproved by the House), he wrote this:
“Given the productivity of the Marcellus shale, it is hard to imagine drillers abandoning such a prolific resource en masse, particularly since many have sunk billions of dollars into acquiring leases, building office parks and training workers.”
Pennsylvania has become the nation’s second-largest producer of natural gas in the past decade, trailing only Texas, despite lower regional gas prices and a limited local labor pool, Mr. Raimi noted.
“If the existing [local] impact fee … did not stop Pennsylvania’s surging production, is it likely than additional 0.7 percent will bring growth to a halt?” he asked.
Read More
Not on your autographed picture of T. Boone Pickens.
That’s the good news. The bad news is this tiny uptick in the tax — from 2.3 percent of production value to about 3 percent — would net only around $90 million, which would add just one-quarter of 1 percent to the state’s tax revenue, at least using 2015 figures, Mr. Raimi wrote.
The state’s situation isn’t any better two years later. This week, Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf urged House Republicans to get moving on a balanced budget or there would be spending cuts. These wouldn’t be the mythical painless cuts of legend either. There was a $1.5 billion shortfall in the last fiscal year and we’re $700 million short of balancing the budget that was supposed to kick in two months ago.
Mr. Wolf already has shoved $700 million from the motor license fund — the money we’re supposed to use to maintain road and bridges — to keep the State Police on sound footing. More than a third of that is a loan that needs to be paid back with interest by March, but that bought time so the state could send money toward school districts.
That sounds less like sound fiscal policy than the checkbook manipulations made at the kitchen table in an old “Roseanne” episode. Those credit scolds at Standard & Poor’s warned Pennsylvania it could be facing a credit downgrade, which would mean a higher rate of interest when this state inevitably needs to borrow again.
One possible balancing plan that is reportedly bouncing around the governor’s office is to cut 12 percent across the board — including more than $700 million from public schools and some $282 million from the agencies that provide homeless assistance, mental health and other health and human services.
It would be obscene if sacrifices are made there without imposing a tax that should have been put in place years ago. Because this is one tax not easily passed on to consumers. Natural gas prices are all about supply and demand. This flea-bite of a tax will have to be sucked up by the drillers if they want their prices to remain competitive with what’s produced in other states.
Think of it as the flip side of the lesson we learned when the city’s parking tax was slashed years ago but the lot and garage fees didn’t drop a penny. Private operators are going to charge whatever the market will allow, and the market reacts independently of any basis costs.
Given all this, let’s finally take the tens of millions of dollars that we’ve left sitting on the table for years. It’s what the big natural gas states do. It also would be at least a baby step toward balancing the Pennsylvania budget before Christmas.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.