Will the HOV lane on the Parkway North always mean “Hardly One Vehicle”?

PennDOT confirms that since it started allowing cars with two people in 1992 — after its three-year experiment requiring three-to-a-car left the lane all but empty — HOV ridership in the peak morning hour is actually down 25 percent.

That’s a little misleading because a third inbound lane opened on the parkway’s mainline in 1993, making the HOV lane less important. Even so, its relative solitude can anger the average commuter sitting alone in traffic.

“Parkway North is a parking lot and yet the HOV lane mocks me every day with nobody on it. How about studying a way to toll it and use it?”

Advertise with us

That was the first online comment below a story last week on Pittsburgh’s “Complete Streets” program, which has nothing to do with HOV lanes. That didn’t stop a skirmish breaking out among cyclists, transit riders and one-to-a-car commuters who already have a tradition of mixing it up below any PG transportation story.

For the record, the HOV lane isn’t empty. PennDOT counted 959 in the average morning peak hour last year, and 987 in the average evening peak. Still, that means the one-to-a-car caravan outnumbered HOV vehicles almost 8-to-1 in the morning rush hour and about 4.5-to-1 at night. In the average day last year, only 5,751 vehicles drove the HOV lane in the restricted hours while 105,635 drove the mainline daily.

Even granting that the HOV lane isn’t open 24/​7, there’s clearly room for growth — and maybe a new source of funding for rapid transit if tolling is allowed.

I called Everett Burns of Cranberry, who began the online debate with his proposal to toll the HOV lane for lone drivers. That’s been done in other states.

He’d suggested online that Mayor Bill Peduto worry more about the HOV lane than he did bicycle lanes, which struck me as unfair. Mr. Peduto wasn’t elected to encourage people to live elsewhere and commute to the city. The city’s millennial population is surging and they and many other city residents ride bicycles. Expecting Mr. Peduto to refigure the HOV is about like expecting the suburban leaders of Amerca’s Largest Full-Time State Legislature to do something about every Pennsylvania city’s problem: big nonprofit employers that don’t pay property or payroll taxes.

Advertise with us

That doesn’t happen because the people who elect them mostly don’t care. Likewise, HOV reform will have to come from the suburbs because, frankly, city residents are somewhat baffled why so many people commuting to the same saturated square mile can’t find a single other person to sit with them.

Mr. Burns, who has been commuting Downtown from Cranberry for 14 years, said he tried to find a commuting partner a few years ago when gasoline was around $4 a gallon. He asked 15 or 20 people but everyone seemed to have different schedules. In Cranberry, he said, “each home is its own island.”

In fairness, I had to call four North Side neighbors Thursday morning before I could find someone willing to drive to the McKnight Road HOV entrance with me for a test drive south. Riding buddies don’t grow on sidewalks or front lawns.

Conversions of HOV lanes to HOT (High-Occupancy Toll) Lanes are permissible under federal law, but it would be PennDOT’s decision. A PennDOT spokesman said Friday that an HOV-to-HOT conversion on I-279 never has been seriously discussed.

HOT lanes are becoming more common. Miami, Atlanta, Dallas-Fort Worth, Los Angeles, Seattle and Minneapolis have them. Those meeting the minimum-rider requirement still don’t pay anything, and solo drivers with an EZ Pass-style account pay to zip to or from work. As long as it doesn’t congest the HOV lane, it can lead to less congestion on all lanes and be good for both commuters and the planet.

Advertise with us

Federal law restricts the toll revenue somewhat, but it can be used to add more routes to the HOV lanes, once the expenses of tolling upgrades are paid. If toll money were dedicated to better mass transit, it could find widespread support.

Mr. Burns said he’d be willing pay $3 a day inbound. That would reap about $720 a year from one car. That might be high and $1 might be too low, but with the right number PennDOT could raise $1 million a year.

Of course, then we’d run the risk of commuting motorists, mass transit riders and cyclists agreeing on something, but there’s a first time for everything.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947.