Everything is getting worse. It’s a major implication of my traditionalism that more and more people seem to be catching onto.
It’s hyperbolic, of course. Knee replacements, for instance, are getting better every year, along with many other medical technologies. Our understanding of the natural world, especially its smallest building blocks, appears to be advancing. The Yemeni mint limeade at the new Socotra Cafe in Brookline is an ambrosia I never expected to enjoy so close to home.
Yet the prevailing American sentiment has shifted decisively to pessimism and decline.
To address the elephant in the room, Donald Trump represents this tendency both ways. His detractors see him as the cause of American decline and his supporters as the only antidote to American decline. Both assume the world is getting worse. Further, the Iran fiasco has moved many Trump-tolerant Americans and even Trump loyalists to seeing him (rightly) as an accelerant of that decline.
I’m not uncomfortable in this situation because my own framework for understanding human affairs is informed by the idea of the long defeat: evil usually has the upper hand, at least in this world. This is not a counsel of despair, however, because goodness is not impotent. We see innumerable examples of goodness, which we should celebrate because every good act is an act of defiance.
And of a hope that is manifest in its fulness during this season of physical and spiritual rebirth.
Hobbit heroism
J.R.R. Tolkien wrote in 1956: “I am a Christian, and indeed a Roman Catholic, so that I do not expect ‘history’ to be anything but a ‘long defeat’ — though it contains (and in a legend may contain more clearly and movingly) some samples or glimpses of final victory.” The idea expressed not only his faith, but his experiences as a soldier in the trenches in the First World War and what he had seen in the world since.
It is the essential framework of “The Lord of the Rings.” The theme is somewhat neutered in the Peter Jackson films by the deletion of the “scouring of the Shire,” in which the evil Saruman (still alive) turns the homeland of the hobbits, who had saved the world from the even more evil Sauron, from an idyllic countryside into an industrial wasteland. The chapter makes clear that the world after the hobbits’ heroism is still worse than the world before it.
But it is so much better than it would have been without their heroism. If anything, the fact of decline only accentuates the beauty of their sacrifice, because it didn’t result in a utopian reward they could enjoy, but rather quietly served their friends and neighbors by preserving them from an even worse fate. And they were able to begin to restore their home.
The entire epic is imbued with bittersweetness, because the good is always threatened by evil, which seems so much more powerful, and always slipping away and in danger of being lost. But the good is still good and worth preserving if possible, though this comes at great cost. The cost is driven home in the last chapter, where Frodo, the main hero, has been too wounded to stay in the homeland he sacrificed so much to save.
Kith and kin
How do we fight the Long Defeat? Few of us are likely to be tasked by a wizard with going on a quest, which will almost certainly end in our deaths, to a volcano named Mount Doom.
Remember how the story begins. Neither Frodo nor his friends set off on a mission to save the world. They set off on a mission to save the Shire. Only in so doing, in acting valiantly to protect kith and kin — who do not know they are in mortal danger — do they end up saving the world.
The long defeat describes the trajectory of humankind over time. It says nothing about the victories that can be won, and the hope that can be kindled, right here and right now. We do this only rarely by grand acts of heroism. Much more frequently, we do this by responding with kindness and charity to the needs of those closest to us, and with integrity and grace to the circumstances of our lives as they develop.
It’s common — and quite relevant at the moment — to observe critically that you can win many battles and still lose the war. But we can also flip the meaning: It’s possible for each of us and our families and communities to engage the battles of everyday life with hope and love, even amid the long defeat. It is possible to have, as Tolkien wrote, “glimpses of final victory.”
Defiant hope
That is what this weekend, beginning with the apparent defeat by death on Good Friday and ending with the real defeat of death on Easter Sunday, is all about. This is for Christians the eternal hope from which all hopes for good in this world descend.
Yet for all of us, regardless of belief, this season of rebirth should remind us that even during the long defeat, there are seasons when the bad retreats and the good flourishes. Even if it is not that season in the field of world affairs, it can be that season in the places and among the people we care about most.
Every flower that comes into bloom from a once-dead tree is an invitation to be a blossom of hope that defies the long defeat, and anticipates the final victory.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Is growth possible in Pittsburgh?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.