The picture should be hung on the wall of every sports bar and hockey rink in America: the young star Jack Hughes, long hair tousled by hard play, fist in the air, draped with Old Glory, smiling broadly with half a tooth missing and others blood-stained, just moments after scoring the nation’s first gold medal goal in 46 years.

Apply a filter and the image could be from 1980 or 1960 for that matter. Rarely does a photograph this timeless and wholesome and perfect come along.

Yet within hours the whole thing seemed tainted, as if one of those European climate activists had splashed acid on the canvas. FBI Director Kash Patel talked his way into the locker room, and President Donald Trump made a snide remark about the (also gold medal) U.S. women’s team, and the men laughed along. Then they went to the White House and the State of the Union, and now a great many Americans see the men’s victory, and that perfect photograph, in a partisan light.

Can we enjoy nothing, not even for a moment, as a united country? Is there anything — courage, excellence, joy, exuberance, patriotism — that transcends partisanship? It seems the answer to these questions is “absolutely not.”

Advertise with us

If that’s the case, the likelihood of a return to anything resembling the political center is all but nil.

Drawn to the extremes

Indeed, a few polls caught my eye this week showing that Americans — especially young Americans — are reaching for the most extreme political options.

In Maine, progressive firebrand Graham Platner is shellacking two-term incumbent governor and establishment pick Janet Mills by nearly 40 points in the Democratic primary for U.S. Senate. More interestingly, the poll shows Platner — who has never held elected office, once identified (facetiously?) as a “communist” and has a tattoo that may or may not be a Nazi totenkopf, or “death’s head” — doing much better than Mills in a general election matchup against longtime GOP Sen. Susan Collins.

More interestingly still, Platner’s advantage expands when only voters ages 18 to 34 are considered.

Then down the coast in Florida, Trump loyalist U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds has a healthy lead in a gubernatorial primary, which could shrink if Casey DeSantis, wife of incumbent Ron DeSantis, enters the race. But the University of North Florida survey also showed that young voters, 18 to 34, strongly prefer political neophyte James Fishback to Donalds, 32% to 8%, with many still undecided.

Advertise with us

Fishback has been associated with the racist, sexist and antisemitic “groyper” movement. Among other troubling statements, he has said that Donalds, who is Black, would “turn Florida into a Section 8 ghetto.” But breaking basic norms of politics and decency appears to be a feature, not a bug, for many young voters.

Disillusionment

This all raises a troubling question: Do the people, and especially the coming generation, even want the warmth and unity that Jack Hughes’ boyish portrait of Americana should inspire?

I think they do. But I also think they don’t believe it’s actually possible. The pang of emotion the photo inspires is closer to mourning than celebration: It’s a feeling of nostalgia for a lost time, not hope for the present or the future.

To the extent there is hope, it seems Americans increasingly believe that it is only through radical people and radical means, not a “return to normalcy,” that a new national unity might be forged. The so-called “normal,” defined by concepts like moderation and civility that curiously always ended up with powerful people having the freedom to do what they willed while leaving everyday folks behind, is to blame for the instability and distrust of the present moment, many young people in particular believe.

“If the rule you followed brought you to this,” asks the haunting Anton Chigurh in “No Country for Old Men,” “of what use was the rule?” It’s a question fewer and fewer Americans have a satisfactory answer to.

Advertise with us

Two hopes

I don’t have one to offer, at least a satisfactory one. But allow me to hazard two thoughts or maybe hopes.

First, I believe the center — that is, a political ethic of pragmatism and cooperation — can still hold at the local level. This is where ideology and abstraction immediately abut the practical realities of life. Local officials have the ability to achieve tangible enhancements in a community’s shared quality of life, in a manner that weighs far greater in voters’ minds than for federal or even state officials.

Put simply: Voters are less likely to reach for the extremes if the center has visibly made their lives better. Any return to something like moderation must begin here.

Second, we all can and must remember, and allow ourselves to appreciate, that there are human goods that transcend politics and partisanship, among them excellence and perseverance and joy. And there is hardly a better way to meditate on that fact than in savoring a perfect piece of art — in this case, a photograph of boyishness and manfulness all in one.

Jack Hughes’ toothless grin and guileless patriotism may not save America, but they can stir in us a shared vision of a country worth loving, even as we disagree profoundly about how to build it.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “We have to be honest about ‘community engagement.’”