About two and a half years ago, I wrote a column making 10 observations about the Golden Triangle. With a new mayor in office and the NFL Draft in two months, it seems like a good time to revisit the question of the present and future of Downtown.
At least a few of these concepts were inspired by an event convened earlier this month by the Urban Land Institute and hosted at Point Park University, which was inspired by the Post-Gazette’s Big Ideas series of editorials and opinion pieces. I’m grateful to Pete Jefferson, a Pittsburgh-based principal at the design consultancy BranchPattern, for conceiving of the event, which brought a variety of practitioners and stakeholders together to tour the Golden Triangle and then brainstorm ideas to help it reach its enormous potential.
Now, to the 10 thoughts.
The old Downtown is never coming back.
No matter how many corporations bring their employees back to the office, there will never be even close to as many daily workers Downtown as before the pandemic. I’ll go further, even though I don’t like saying it: Downtown is simply overbuilt for this economic era. It will continue to bleed to its periphery — the North Shore, the Strip District, (eventually) the Lower Hill. Residential conversions will only go so far. Policymakers must consider what a thinned-out, greener urban core might look like.
Corollary: Tearing down the BNY Mellon Center must be on the table.
I’ve yet to see a workable plan to fill its 1.7 million square feet of space once the bank’s master lease on the Met Life-owned tower expires in 2028. The 17-story ancillary tower could remain as an homage, perhaps as another residential conversion. The rest of the land would immediately become one of the best urban infill opportunities in America. Transit center? New building tailored to today’s needs? Exceptional urban park?
Perception is a matter of proportion.
I don’t think there are more people panhandling or struggling with behavioral or mental health in Downtown than there were before the pandemic. But the lack of people in the Golden Triangle for work, entertainment or other business makes this human-services challenge much more visible. In other words: Downtown would look and feel safer if there were more people there. Besides adding housing and bringing workers in, I’d like to see the Oakland/Uptown colleges consider adding student housing Downtown, once PRT’s University Line is up and running.
Smithfield Street remains the key corridor for improvements.
It is very encouraging that the O’Connor administration is following through on a Peduto-era plan to rebuild Smithfield Street, with a particular emphasis on pedestrian friendliness. It’s still Downtown’s Main Street and could be the catalyst for a retail revival. Target is thriving. Bringing 500 Smithfield (the old Mellon Bank) back online is essential. Mellon Square should be a crown jewel, not a forgotten void. Whichever way Smithfield goes, so goes Downtown as a whole.
Something has to be done about the Boulevard of the Allies.
It’s a useless asphalt laceration that splits Point Park University in two and cuts off Downtown from First Avenue and the Monongahela riverfront. There is absolutely no need for five lanes of traffic in the middle of the Golden Triangle. The Boulevard was a City Beautiful-era project, but now it’s ugly as sin. Make it a real boulevard: fewer lanes, wide median, street trees. It would instantly make the Mon side feel closer to the thriving Allegheny side.
The Cultural District is still exceptional.
Speaking of the Allegheny side: Dinner and a show along Penn and its cross streets is still one of the best small-city cultural experiences in this country. Cleaning up Liberty Avenue of the vape shops would make it even better.
Find another block (or several) to give the Penn Avenue treatment.
The coolest area of Downtown is Penn between 10th and Ninth: street trees, outdoor dining, bike lane, one lane of slow one-way traffic. It’s safe, walkable and beautiful. What about Forbes from Market Square to Wood or even all the way to Smithfield, past the Pittsburgh Playhouse?
Restaurateurs need help building out promising spaces.
It’s not necessarily the rent that’s keeping prime dining spots empty, even in the Cultural District: It’s the high six- or even seven-figure cost of building out a new space. The city should work with foundations and Downtown stakeholders to create a fund to offer low-interest build-out loans. Dining options will quickly fill in vacant spots.
Aesthetics matter.
I recently met someone from overseas on his first visit to Pittsburgh, and he marveled at the quality and diversity of architecture Downtown. It makes it all the more discouraging, then, when façades and sidewalks are crumbling or when garish vape shops occupy the first floors of grand old 19th century walkups. Bringing upkeep up to the level of the architecture would go a long way toward making Downtown a place people want to be.
Downtown needs you.
The Golden Triangle still has the best bones of any mid-size-city downtown in America. It needs some TLC in several aspects of the built environment. But what it mostly needs is Pittsburghers (and visitors) to give it a shot. See a show. Grab a bite. I think you’ll find that the most dystopian descriptions are overblown. And you might just want to come back.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Performative progressive politics will melt away like the snow (eventually).”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.